CreateDebate


Debate Info

18
1
Yes No
Debate Score:19
Arguments:12
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (11)
 
 No (1)

Debate Creator

Tugman(749) pic



If Humans have souls would Aliens have them as well?

I have been asking myself this question.  What do you folks think?

The alien I am talking about is the one that would be in Flying saucer not a bacteria.

Yes

Side Score: 18
VS.

No

Side Score: 1
2 points

Actually, even the bacteria aliens would have souls. I tend to believe in Plato's version of the three levels of a soul. The most basic is the nutritive soul, which all life has. It is the soul that contains a want for growth and reproduction- the basic life cycles. The next level is the sensitive soul, which all animals have. That would be the soul that allows us to feel and react with others and the environment. The most complex soul would be the rational soul, found only in humans because we possess the ability to think rationally, unlike any other animal on Earth. I'm sure if an alien can build a spacecraft, he would have a rational soul as well. :)

Side: yes

Yes, why not? If one is of the belief system in which one has a soul, why would that necessarily be reserved for humans? To alien beings...we are aliens as well. If we have souls, then why would they be different?

Side: yes
1 point

That is completely true, I agree, but it also depends onyour personal definition of a soul. Everyone has different experiences

Side: yes
1 point

keyword if

since there is no such thing as a soul, only a brain that is self-aware, and aware of mortality, and doesn't want to not exist anymore.

but, if a god is responsible for making stuff, and decided some sentient beings should live forever, I cannot imagine even the christian god would be such an incredible ass as to deprive other sentient beings of that eternal life.

and if he is that big of an ass, he can go f--k himself, I'll chill in my grave with the rest of the "unworthies" and he can keep his eternal life.

Side: yes
1 point

QUOTE:

"since there is no such thing as a soul, only a brain that is self-aware, and aware of mortality, and doesn't want to not exist anymore"

Hey, have you read Eckhart Tolle? :o)

Side: yes
1 point

hm, I had never heard of him, but I just read a few of his quotes.

he sounds very humanistic at least initially, which I like, though I disagree we "leek energy" from our head. but those spiritual types always have a few crazy ideas thrown in with the good ones.

Side: yes
1 point

IF I believed in souls, and aliens, then ya, I'd believe they had them too. I'd believe animals have them too. Anything with a heart has some soul. :-)

Side: yes
1 point

It should have a soul if it do exist.any living creature have one..

Side: yes
-1 points

Only sons of Jesus can have souls and therefore only humans can have souls. All other creatures are filthy and they are servants to humans.

Side: No
Pineapple(1449) Disputed
4 points

I don't want any servants. I can't believe if there is a God, he'd be all rude and exclusive like that.

Side: yes
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
3 points

I was under the impression that jesus was a virgin...

and what about daughters? so god's not only a slave master, but a sexist one at that?

Side: yes