CreateDebate


Debate Info

10
12
Pursuant to right wingers, YES Pursuant to left wingers, NO
Debate Score:22
Arguments:15
Total Votes:25
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Pursuant to right wingers, YES (7)
 
 Pursuant to left wingers, NO (8)

Debate Creator

excon(18260) pic



If I gave a guy the finger, and he advances on me, can I stand my ground and kill him??

Pursuant to right wingers, YES

Side Score: 10
VS.

Pursuant to left wingers, NO

Side Score: 12

As someone who is more left wing than you, I think it depends on the situation. Assault is not justified just because someone gives you the finger but killing someone is not justified if you can take them in a fist fight without killing them.

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES
excon(18260) Disputed
1 point

killing someone is not justified if you can take them in a fist fight without killing them.

Hello hater:

And, you have the nerve to insult the retarded..

Dude!

excon

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
Bootstrap(226) Disputed
3 points

you have the nerve to insult the retarded.

Not all retarded people. Just you.

I've noticed that whenever anybody insults you personally, you pretend they are talking about the entire race/religion/demographic of which you (usually falsely) claim to be part of.

That is called being a dishonest prick. You should be a dishonest prick less often.

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES
1 point

The only problem here is your inability to understand what I say because you are a retard. In a way you are disagreeing with yourself right now just to say something bitchy towards me.

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES

Did he propose a one night stand?

--------------------------------------

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES

You're thinking like an emotional woman and putting feelings first again. Me hurting your feelings with the middle finger isn't a crime or threatening. You trying to assault me in return IS.

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES
2 points

Retarded question. You can't justify killing someone for "advancing on you". We all walk towards people all the time.

Kill yourself.

For being so fucking stupid.

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
excon(18260) Disputed
0 points

We all walk towards people all the time

Hello s:

Yeah, I wondered if anybody would MISUNDERSTAND the term, "advancing on me", and I was right.. But, I thought it would be one of the more stupid ones... Guess not..

excon

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES
Bootstrap(226) Disputed
2 points

Yeah, I wondered if anybody would MISUNDERSTAND the term, "advancing on me", and I was right.. But, I thought it would be one of the more stupid ones... Guess not.

Shut up you idiot. The only stupid person in this debate is you. You can't even make a point without abusing caps lock. Piss off. You define "smart" as a measure of whether somebody agrees with you or not.

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
1 point

If you're a retard, does that mean the people you think are retards are actually smart?

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
2 points

No. First you don't know his intent, second escalating the violence isn't a form of self-defense, alternatively....in the world we live in now, he could say he was acting in self-defense as well.

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
1 point

No. First you don't know his intent,

Hello Mint:

Girl.. You are one smart cookie.. I raised the question because that very thing actually happened to me..

I don't remember the exact circumstances, but I didn't like the way somebody was driving, so I gave him the finger.. Lo and behold, I happened to find myself on a dead end street.

Well, this guy "advanced on me".. In other words, he came at me with anger in his eyes.. Frankly, he scared the shit outta me.. I thought he was gonna clean my clock.. Under current stand your ground laws, I WAS in fear for my life and legally COULD have shot him..

But, I didn't have a gun.. Good thing too, because all the guy did was yell at me.. I learned a good lesson too..

I liked the old self defense laws.. They said that IF you have the means to escape, you MUST take it.. That's sooo much better than STANDING there and shooting somebody..

excon

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
Bootstrap(226) Disputed
2 points

Girl.. You are one smart cookie.

Understanding that the human race isn't telepathic might qualify you as smart in the US, but in the rest of the world it is just perfectly normal.

Side: Pursuant to right wingers, YES
1 point

-------------------------------------- DELETED ----------------------------------------

checking some hack options

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO
1 point

Probably not, unless you have a legitimate fear of death, or grievous bodily harm. No one is is going to say you can't defend yourself, you just can't kill an unarmed person, unless you are in a red state, then you can kill any minority you want. Sad fucking truth about the right. #Progressive2020

Side: Pursuant to left wingers, NO