Debate Score:	11
Arguments:	7
Total Votes:	19
More Stats

If a German elected Hitler knowing he supported killing Jews, would the voter be culpable?

Democrat voters keep telling us they are not responsible for killing viable unborn babies when electing politicians who vow to keep No Restriction abortions legal.

So tell me, would that same denial hold water when a German voted to keep Hitler in power? The German tells everyone he was personally against killing Jews, and is not responsible for dead Jewish people when helping to elect Hitler.

Does that make any sense to you? Me neither!

Add New Argument

MKIced (2511)

1 point

Yes. If someone votes for a politician whose sole platform is about killing off a minority, then YES that person is indirectly culpable for the end result. Should they necessarily be punished for it? Probably not (depending on level of involvement).

Hitler killing Jews and various other minorities is unequivocal to any form of abortion. This is a worrisome comparison as one example takes millions of people regardless of their character and tortures and kills them simply due to their religious affiliation. The other example is deeply personal. Abortions are performed every day on nonviable fetuses, women who have to decide between paying rent and having a baby, women who have been raped (even by their fathers, their brothers, etc). Shame on you for even thinking of comparing the two.

4 years ago

Support Dispute Clarify

↓ Show Replies

FromWithin (8241) Disputed

-3 points

First off, thank you for actually responding to this debate. Most Pro choicers on this site refuse to do so.

Now let me say, shame on you for once again bringing the abortion debate down to extreme cases.

I keep extreme case abortions separate from these discussions because the VAST VAST VAST VAST majority of abortions are done for convenience, and the GOP is not disputing extreme case abortions.

The GOP tried to compromise and pass a 20 week limit abortion Bill (still allowing extreme cases), AND STILL the Democrat Party in an almost unison vote refused to compromise. They want all abortions legal for any reason up to birth!

You said and I quote... "This is a worrisome comparison as one example takes millions of people regardless of their character and tortures and kills them simply due to their religious affiliation. The other example is deeply personal."

How is this different from millions of babies being tortured and killed (late term viable babies do feel pain and are being dismembered), regardless their character, simply due to their inconvenience.

I'm sure killing Jews was also deeply personal and has nothing to do with the legalized killing of innocent human lives simply out of convenience. DO NOT BRING UP EXTREME CASES!

Separate out the non viable lives at this moment and deal with what you support when voting for these extreme pro abortion Democrats.

Just to give you some data on late term abortions... In 2015 in the United States, about 1.3% of abortions took place after the 21st week. So if there are approximately 900,000 abortions per year in the US, 1.3% would be approximately 1200 late term abortions per year.

So would you have been OK with killing 1200 Jews when electing Hitler? How many lives does it take to affect your vote?

Ask yourself why the Democrat Party refuses to compromise with the GOP and pass a simple Bill that would protect viable babies (that are not extreme cases) from being killed?

The answer is POLITICS! The Democrat Party is tied hip line and sinker to radical Feminist and Pro abortion lobbies! They have sold their souls for money and votes!

When you vote for these extremists, you ARE culpable. It matters not what lives are being killed, it is inhuman.

Innocent Life must always be protected and thereby send an example to all the world, that no Government has the right to take innocent life regardless their age or location.

We have mothers who think it is OK to throw their new born babies into dumpsters because they have become so desensitized from abortions of these innocent human lives.

4 years ago