CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:30
Arguments:32
Total Votes:33
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 If an unborn baby is not alive, why are its body parts of value (26)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



If an unborn baby is not alive, why are its body parts of value

Add New Argument
2 points

Dead people don't swim, sperms swim.

Dead people don't have heart beats, they do.

Dead people don't make turns or moves, they do

Dead people don't eat, they are always they eating

Etc......

Kinda seem like alive already, ain't it?

Stop talking common sense. That is not politically correct. We must all become braindead animals and swallow the lies from the Left.

It's a choice don't you know? Not a living growing innocent life.

jeffreyone(1383) Clarified
1 point

"Stop talking common sense"

I am being generous to share with the less priviledged. (dermot, mintea etc who condone abortion)

Christian like.

Narek(89) Disputed
1 point

Stop talking common sense.

Ah so you're finally admitting you hate common sense.

2 points

You pose a question of fact, not a question of debate.

The body parts have value because they can be used for research and/or for transplant even though their original owner no longer can use them.

An unborn baby is obviously alive to any compassionate sane rational thinking human being.

Those who dissagree are totally self absorbed people whose convienence outweighs an innocent life. They behave like the very animals they believe we evolved from.

1 point

You could have guessed this void-of-all-logic debate was going to be by Bronto right? Haha

0 points

A fetus may be alive, but so is an ant. Unless you value ants equally to fetuses, life alone isn't enough to make something of value. You need a better reason.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

So if we deam your life of no value, we should be able to end it?

Mack(531) Disputed
1 point

If we deem an ant's life of no value should we be able to end it?

All I said was that life itself is not the factor that makes certain killings wrong if it is okay to kill an ant, and that you should provide a better reason than 'it's alive' to make the argument that it is wrong to kill a fetus.

With respect to your question I'm not sure whether anybody 'should' be able to do anything, so can't give an answer.