CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:27
Arguments:29
Total Votes:29
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 If colleges stopped looking at ACT scores, what should they focus on when admitting? (27)

Debate Creator

HTHAMES(46) pic



If colleges stopped looking at ACT scores, what should they focus on when admitting?

What would you substitute for the ACT and why?
Add New Argument
1 point

I like them to focus on a test that's like the ACT but the one thing the test wouldn't have is the time limit of the test.

ChocolateFug(3) Disputed
1 point

I think they could look at grades or have the same guidelines as the ACT on a regular basis to have a more of a secure way of taking test it'd be more accurate.

MKOP(5) Disputed
1 point

Grades could be the same for a person who tries and didn't try in school. Maybe have the same guide line for the ACT but give at least a better time limit.

1 point

Colleges should look for GPA, involvement in clubs in the school and involvement in the community.

1 point

I agree because an ACT doesn't always define a person either looking at clubs or GPA may be a better option

1 point

GPA. GPA is a big factor in highschool because its what grades the students made in the class and its there overall GPA in highschool. It is what the students keep up with through there highschool career.

1 point

Focus on “hard factors” (GPA, grades, and test scores) and “soft factors” (essays, extracurricular activities, recommendations, and demonstrated interest) to gain a full picture of applicants.

1 point

They should focus on recommendations from teachers that have worked with said student.

1 point

GPA and college essay. I think the students college essay should be very impactful because you hear what they are really about. GPA is also very important because it shows how the student academically performs.

1 point

I know for Art colleges go by art portfolio as well as ACT but the ACT isn't just one thing they're looking at. So if they weren't looking at ACT then they should go by portfolios, essays, high school grades, GPA, extracurricular we've been in, and attendance.

1 point

They should focus on ur GPA. act tests are mad confusing so they should go off of how good we actually are and not on a district-made test

1 point

they should care about GPA. Act scores really shouldn't matter at all.

1 point

If colledes stopped looking at ACT scores then they should start looking at grades.

1 point

If colleges stopped looking at ACT scores, they should start focusing on a person's interest in the subject they want to pursue such as, art, medication, or even science. They should also look into extracurricular activities/groups/organizations the student has partaken in. College essays are also a great way to learn what the students' intentions are and how in-depth their interests are for their desired majors.

1 point

I agree with this one. There are other ways to find a great college that meet your passion in that career field. This also helps out the people that have a harder time taking the ACT because its confusing and only limited time.

1 point

The main focus when admitting for a college instead of the act should be on you as a person. In my opinion, the act score does not tell someone about you. If colleges wanted to know how you will do at their school they can look at your grades or behavioral status.

1 point

Colleges should focus on the students overall grade and how their grades improved or declined over the 4 years of high school that way they can see if the student will improve the school test scores for the college.

1 point

GPA and attendance becuase giving a high requirment many people will be filtered out

1 point

I think they would start focusing in on grades and performance in junior and senior years in high school, not everyone can take the ACT as well as

others.

1 point

If colleges stopped looking at ACT scores, I think that they would look at your grades, GPA, and extra activities that you're in

0 points

If colleges stopped looking at ACT scores, I believe that they should focus more on GPA and extracurricular activities. I say that because those honestly matter way more than the ACT could ever. The ACT doesn't even estimate how much you know. The ACT is there to just estimate test taking skills and time management. You can be one of the smartest kids ever and have horrible test taking anxiety. Meanwhile, your GPA at school reflects all the hard work you put in, all the assignments you have aced, and just an actual showcase of your knowledge compared to a 4 hour test. With extracurricular activities, colleges should really start to looking at that because involved students are some of the best students that there is. If you have a 3.7 GPA and are involved in like 8 clubs, I think that shows way more than a 30+ on the ACT could mean.

MKOP(5) Disputed
1 point

A person with advance class could have the same GPA as a person without advance classes. Also, take the same extracurricular activities. It's also not just about the numbers but also the personality.

jtaylor23(13) Clarified
1 point

I didn't say anything about advanced classes. I said GPA. Me personally, I feel as if honors and regulars classes touch on the exact same basis; one class just teaches faster in opposition to the other one. I agree with the personality part.

1 point

So I have some questions. Do you think that involvement in the community is an important factor that colleges should look at? Another question is if all of these factors were focused on more than the ACT then should the ACT still matter?

jtaylor23(13) Clarified
1 point

I think involvement in the community is a huge factor that colleges look over due to them wanting students to just be walking test scores to benefit them and make their school looks better. I think the ACT should only matter if it is helping you but it should not be as important as it is right now. Involvement within the community shows that you are a good person and I think that good people are top tier opposed to "smart" people.