CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:12
Arguments:9
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 If you could kick just one state out of the union, which one would it be? (9)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



If you could kick just one state out of the union, which one would it be?

Add New Argument
2 points

Before I can properly answer that, Hellno2012, I need to know what state you live in!....just kidding.

I think I might go with Texas on this one. I think they would probably make a better trading partner than member-state. Plus they are trying, and coming rather close to succeeding, to re-write our history and science textbooks. And I don't know if I will ever forgive them for the Bush regime.

Texas should definitely be able to get out from under the Union's thumb.

1 point

Really, its a win-win situation! They want to do it on their own, they are economically strong enough to do it, they would be able to take whatever wacky approach to border protection they want. The rest of the US, meanwhile, can finally get on with living in reality. Though the temptation to "mess with Texas" might be mighty high. :)

1 point

California! Full of liberal idiots and it's nothing but a drain on our resources!

2 points

Definitely.They'll drift away in some million years anyway. We don't need to spend money on sending them resources!

1 point

Alaska.

We bought it because of Russia, we don't need them, they cost the nation more than they contribute, and Canada is a stout ally so giving it to them would cost us 0 as far as available military bases.

Plus I bet our fish would be cheaper if we imported it from Canada than buy it from Alaska.

-6 points
1 point

I don't and I agree! They're nothing but a bunch of clueless liberal whack-jobs! Let's see how well they do on their own?! LOL

Side: Massachusetts
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

They're one of the few states that contribute to the nation,

TX, CA, ND, NC, FL... blah that's what I know off hand,

Point is, most states cost the country more than they contribute. Massachusetts and most of the New England States actually contribute overall to the national cause.

My vote is infact Alaska. Cold war's over so we don't need it, and what have they given us since becoming a State? Palin, that's it.

Give it to Canada and I bet our fish would be cheaper too.

Side: alaska