CreateDebate


Debate Info

14
6
Mars Saturn
Debate Score:20
Arguments:18
Total Votes:25
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Mars (13)
 
 Saturn (5)

Debate Creator

alstars(736) pic



If you were selected by the Nasa for a space expedition, Which planet would you visit?

Mars

Side Score: 14
VS.

Saturn

Side Score: 6
1 point

First off, why is NASA now "the NASA"?

Also, why do I only get two choices? Maybe I wanted to visit Pluto, which will always be a planet in my eyes. Or maybe I don't want to leave Earth.

Side: Mars
0 points

dear,

sorry to disappoint you.

i just wanted to find out how many of you like mars.

Saturn is more attractive, i guess.

May be you are right, all right

i will recreate a debate with not just two choices.

and my first invitation is for you!

Side: Mars
1 point

Seeing as Saturn, while larger and more scenic, is a gas planet, you can't actually go there. You can visit the surroundig moons, though, which would be my preference.

But I'm realistic, and would prefer to visit mars.

Mars expeditions are plausible in this era, and even though most experts agree that the best way to put humans on Mars is to send them there for good, I'd still do it.

Beauty is negotiable. Earth is probably the most amazing and beautiful place in our solar system, and the surface of mars is bland and desertlike. But it would be a unique beauty that a very few people have been able to enjoy.

Just as all astronauts risk their lives to travel beyond our planet, I would trade life here for that experience.

Side: Mars
1 point

Yeah that's kind of what I was thinking to but I don't like to be realistic. (;

Why can't you go to a gas planet? Oh well, I guess I could settle for one of the moons. You'd have an EPIC view of Saturn from there.

Side: Saturn
1 point

Because it's made of gas. But if you really want to go, I won't stop you.

Side: Mars
1 point

Out of just those two choices I'd pick Mars, because we can learn the most about the history of our own planet and our solar system from studying Mars, and because it's one of the very few objects in space other than Earth that we might have a likely hope of someday putting people on. But if I had my choice of anywhere in the solar system I'd definetely pick Europa, because it's the only thing in the neighborhood other than our own planet that might have life on it.

Side: Europa
1 point

Well seeming as Saturn is mostly gas, and hardly any rocky part to actually stand on, i will go for Mars. Although, if it was one of Saturns rocky moons i may say there!

Side: Mars
1 point

this bloody red planet is said to be having some kind of aliens in themmm

i will go and check it out myself.. hey wait... i am scared to be alone out there

can anyone accompany me?

Side: Mars
1 point

mars 'coz i love red chicks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! .......................................................................................................................................................

Side: Mars
alstars(736) Disputed
0 points

HEY you...

i will get you in school tomorrow !

you think i don't get the meaning of RED CHICKS?

Side: Saturn

It would be really difficult to visit the surface of the planet Saturn because it is a giant gas planet, which means you would be crushed by the pressure further into atmosphere.

So, Mars would be a much more practical expedition because well, it has a surface.

Side: Mars
1 point

I would visit Fox News so I could learn about a different culture and spread the word of science.

Side: Fox News
JakeJ(3255) Disputed
1 point

Wow I thought this debate would be safe from crap like that but I guess not.

Side: Mars
1 point

Mars is over rated. And why would you go there when you could just go to a desert with more oxygen?? Looks about the same only more convienient and less expensive. (:

Saturn is the coolest and it would be cool to look at the rings from a different angle.

Side: Saturn

Saturn it is because I am fascinated by the gaseous rings circling it.

Side: Saturn
benjyfat07(1) Disputed
1 point

I think that you're thinking of Jupiter. Saturn doesn't have gaseous rings. It has a lot of tiny rocks orbiting around it. The only thing interesting about Saturn is that it has a moon made of gasoline. Mar's isn't that interesting either but at least we can land there.

Side: Mars
1 point

saturn 'coz im disc freak and think that it must be called the goddess of love ................................................................................................................................................

Side: Saturn
alstars(736) Disputed
0 points

you better have a one view opinion.

you support mars and saturn?

Side: Mars