CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
3
Ambulance Drone
Debate Score:5
Arguments:4
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Ambulance (2)
 
 Drone (2)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



In a health emergency do you want an ambulance or a drone?

Ambulance

Side Score: 2
VS.

Drone

Side Score: 3
1 point

Either one that can get to the person in need safely and either provide assistance or get them to assistance faster, is what I want.

The drone has the benefit of bypassing traffic, the ambulance has the benefit of having more people to provide immediate assistance. So for me, whichever one can be best use to save a life or help a person faster.

Side: Ambulance
0 points

If you're impaled on a wooden fence you're going to want a human's gentle touch, not a drone. And if you're hanging on for dear life struggling to stay conscious until an ambulance shows up and instead here comes a drone you might just give up and let go right then.

Side: Ambulance
2 points

ambulance drone is a best option for the rescue of victim who can be survived if first aid is given to him in time because, with the increasing traffic, arrival of EMS is becoming late. sometimes it may also take more time if the driver is not very clear about the address and drones can overcome this as they work on GPS. recent reports by researchers revealed that these drones are able to rush to the emergency spot faster than EMS. It is also expected that with the help of drones cardiac arrest survival rates can be increased to 80%. so we can be able to rescue people in more numbers if we are able to build more drone networks instead of EMS crew.

Side: Drone
1 point

Drones are able to traverse much more difficult terrain. The fact that they don't have to abide by roads and travel up a potentially very steep incline by road is a lot better. Even if the drone wasn't really able to tend to me but diagnose me on what is wrong that would help tremendously. It would also help in crowded cities where traffic jams can prevent Ambulances from getting from one place to another. Even if in the beginning they won't be able to tend to you they would still be able to help EMS's figure out what is wrong quicker.

Drone Saves man from Heart Attack
Side: Drone