CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
5
Conservatives=Conservatives Liberals=Conservatives
Debate Score:9
Arguments:10
Total Votes:10
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Conservatives=Conservatives (4)
 
 Liberals=Conservatives (4)

Debate Creator

shaash(434) pic



Iran, USA, what's the difference?

The question I would like to pose is:
Is there a big difference between conservatives in the USA and in Iran?

Obviously, some are conservatively Muslim, and some are conservatively Christian. It seems to me they have similar viewpoints, even though they both hate each other (death to the West vs. The Quran promotes terrorism).
The other option is that US Liberals are closer to Iranian Conservatives.

Conservatives=Conservatives

Side Score: 4
VS.

Liberals=Conservatives

Side Score: 5

They are both ideologically conservative, so conservative = conservative. That isn't to say that conservatives in Iran and Conservatives here are the same, or that their ideology is the same.

Kind of a big C little c situation.

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives
1 point

Do you find it ironic that even though they have extremely similar ideologies, they still dislike each other much more than they would dislike a liberal Iranian.

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives
IAmSparticus(1516) Clarified
1 point

Eh, somewhat. Conservatism tends to have very strong ties to nationalism and religion, which are obviously at odds here. When so much of one's identity is predicated upon two characteristics that are opposed to this other Conservative group, it seems only natural for them to be strongly conflicted.

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives
1 point

Whoever wrote this debate question seems to know as much about political science and theology as Lindsay Lohan does about quantum mechanics.

They also REALLY need to look up the following words..........

Theocracy

Fundamentalist

Liberal

Christianity

Democracy

Maybe after learning those definitions and a US Government 101 class you can phrase your questions on global politics so it makes even a tiny bit of sense.

Thanks.

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives
2 points

If you read the description instead of just the title, it becomes clear that he is alluding to the nature of the Conservative factions within each country and whether their ideological similarities warrant a real comparison.

Side: Liberals=Conservatives
shaash(434) Disputed
1 point

Please read the description before trash talking me :/

And if there was any confusion, I was talking about social conservatism.

Side: Liberals=Conservatives
0 points

The climate it is much warmer over in Iran than here in the USA

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives
1 point

American conservatism typically promotes of a small government and freedom; Iranian conservatism is totalitarian.

Side: Liberals=Conservatives
1 point

I've got to go with Enlighten on this one. Although I'm no fan of American conservatives they have definite differences from their counterparts in Iran and the small government vs totalitarian government difference is the biggest one.

Side: Liberals=Conservatives
shaash(434) Clarified
1 point

Okay, but what about their social ideologies? Muslims wants Sharia law to be instated, Christians want Christian law. Don't they overlap... a lot?

Side: Conservatives=Conservatives