CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
9
Cold Blooded Killer Stupid School Girl
Debate Score:15
Arguments:11
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Cold Blooded Killer (5)
 
 Stupid School Girl (6)

Debate Creator

addltd(5144) pic



Is Amanda Knox a Cold Blooded Killer?

Do you think Amanda Knox killed Meredith Kercher Meredith Kercher, or is unjustly accused?

Apparently, she will find out if hete far is going to significantly change on Monday when the Italian judicial system will rule on her appeal.

http://abcnews.go.com/International/amanda-knox-back-prison-cell-await-mondays-verdict/story?id=14636298

Cold Blooded Killer

 

Stupid School Girl

 

Cold Blooded Killer

Side Score: 6
VS.

Stupid School Girl

Side Score: 9

Maybe she's both. Maybe she's a stupid, cold blooded, school girl killer ;)

Side: Cold Blooded Killer
1 point

I believe she and her boyfriend did it! I don't think she acted alone, therefore I think her original sentence was fair...by the way, does anyone know why she got one more year than her boyfriend the first time around?

Side: Cold Blooded Killer
1 point

hmmm i think bcz her alibi was obviously fake, she said tht she took a shower, then grabbed a mop...then realized that there was blood on the sink and the floor...tht made no sense...it was clear tht she was lying or hiding something. plus if she took a shower without realizing tht there is blood everywhere...then she must be blind...and she also hated her...so i guess there was evidence to throw her away more than her boyfriend...

Side: Cold Blooded Killer
2 points

She's been sentenced on DNA on only the knife? And there's a third party known criminal?

I wouldn't take the article for the whole truth, and it's ambiguous enough as it is... Probably just another girl swept along into doing something idiotic.

Side: Stupid School Girl

It is sad to see a innocent woman thrown in jail without concrete evidence.

Side: Stupid School Girl
saprophetic(390) Disputed
1 point

I wouldn't say innocent. There's enough evidence to say she was involved, but why she was is anyone's guess.

Side: Cold Blooded Killer
2 points

There's enough evidence to say she was involved,

Which is to say that the evidence is circumstantial.

Side: Stupid School Girl
1 point

Who the hell knows? I doubt even she does... she was probably so doped up that night she has no memory of it.

Side: Stupid School Girl
0 points

I wouldn't say she's cold-blooded. She is stupid, though. Stupid, selfish, cowardly. And--at the very least--a good example of why not every woman should be forced into motherhood even though she is biologically capable.

Side: Stupid School Girl