CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
4
Fangirls are bullies No it isn't, it fine.
Debate Score:5
Arguments:5
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Fangirls are bullies (1)
 
 No it isn't, it fine. (4)

Debate Creator

philchester(5) pic



Is Being A Fangirl Bullying?

So as we all know the internet has been growing to be a home for girls to create a domain full of fans, which is as well called a fandom. The thing is that recently as celebs and youtubers to be specific are interacting more and more with their fans... There have been problem as it goes for privacy and feeling comfortable for the celeb or the youtuber. Which then evolves into ships, which then evolves into fanfiction (some in which are smut and erotic). So with the invasion of privacy and the erotic fanfics they write, is this a new form of bullying that we have not discussed.

Fangirls are bullies

Side Score: 1
VS.

No it isn't, it fine.

Side Score: 4
1 point

i think you might be right. the resultant effect can be similar to bullying, but the intent is not unimportant. obviously the fangirl does not intend to harm its idol. as for the issue of privacy, i can see it as a problem, but you could also say it is part of the job title. most careers have a specific image that you are aware of prior to taking up the career. fame brings with it infringements of privacy, which is to keep the fame going. the example you mention perhaps to some or many may be taken as a step too far and even considered bullying, but it would depend on how much 'fame' the object is willing to take.

if you want to be a fisherman, you can't justifiably complain about the smell of fish.

Side: Fangirls are bullies
1 point

No its not, there are different kinds of fangirls. The bully fangirls and behave fangirls. You can't tell fangirls are bullys if you don't know all the fangirls and you've never been a fangirl. And by the way fangirls don't bully people unless people don't bully or say something bad about they're idol.

Side: No it isn't, it fine.
1 point

No its not, there are different kinds of fangirls. The bully fangirls and behave fangirls. You can't tell fangirls are bullys if you don't know all the fangirls and you've never been a fangirl. And by the way fangirls don't bully people unless people don't bully or say something bad about they're idol.

Side: No it isn't, it fine.

I think the majority of fangirls have a positive outlook and do not want to see their idol disgraced in any way.

Side: No it isn't, it fine.
1 point

Only the mentally insane fangirls are bullies, who do what you've described above. I'm personally not in any fandoms that involve real people. I like cartoon fandoms, where I can express my opinions and ship whoever I want. While I'd dislike being shipped as a celeb, that's kind of what you have to expect. As for smut, that's a different story. That's an invasion of privacy and, quite honestly, a disgrace to your idol.

Side: No it isn't, it fine.