CreateDebate


Debate Info

276
343
violence peace
Debate Score:619
Arguments:156
Total Votes:704
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 violence (60)
 
 peace (75)

Debate Creator

MohamedAli(78) pic



Is Islam a religion of violence or a religion of peace?

violence

Side Score: 276
VS.

peace

Side Score: 343
15 points

The entire religion is about aggression and the oppression of self for the sake of serving a sexist society as a whole.

Side: violence
Jace(5222) Clarified
14 points

Out of curiosity, do you consider this a distinguishing factor in Islam from other religions?

Side: violence
Hitler(2364) Disputed
14 points

No.

It's just the most overt in how it achieves this and the lowest IQ of all religions (although Scientology is possibly worse).

Side: peace
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
9 points

Islam's most fundamental concept is a rigorous monotheism :)

Side: peace
13 points

Not to mention Jihad. Christianity is also similar to Islam in this regard.

Side: violence
Srom(12206) Disputed
14 points

Christianity is also similar to Islam in this regard.

LOL, no it's not similar to Islam in this regard.

Side: peace
Tachmonite(36) Disputed
13 points

Not to mention Jihad. Christianity is also similar to Islam in this regard.

"38 Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth:

39 But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also."

-Matt 5:38-39

Yep. Completely similar.

Side: violence
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
10 points

Did Jesus ever kill anyone? No

Did Jesus ever capture sex slaves? No

Did Jesus ever call on his followers to fight? No

Did Muhammad kill anyone? Yes, ( see Massacre of Banu Qurayza for example)

Did Muhammad capture sex slaves? Yes (he had rights to 20% of all spoils from conquest and fathered a son from a slave)

Did Muhammad ever call on his followers to fight? Yes (he even threatened them with damnation in Hell if they did not)

Side: peace
ffemt333(51) Clarified
8 points

Do you even know what Jihad is? It means a holy war. As i said in my other argument, extremists are brain washed. They think they are doing the right thing and fight a Jihad.

Side: violence
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
8 points

Islam's most fundamental concept is a rigorous monotheism :)

Side: peace
ffemt333(51) Disputed
7 points

No, Not at all. yes I'm not Islam. But i know enough to say it is not Islam, it's extremists. yes extremists generally do come from Islamic religion. But that doesn't mean all Islams are terrorists. That is a racist belief. Extremists, for example the late Osama Bin Laden, take the words of the Islamic religion and twisted them to serve his purpose. and effectively brainwashed his organization. So the aggressive acts committed by these extremists, are what the believe to be the right thing to do.

Side: peace
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
9 points

That is a racist belief.

Explain to me how exactly Islam is a race.

Side: violence
robag2000(65) Disputed
1 point

Are you a Muslim? Have you read the Koran? I haven't so I can't say it's a violent religion. I don't know if what you say is true but if it is, I will switch my side to "violent".

Side: peace
12 points

And he (Ishmael) will be a wild man; his hand will be against every man, and every man's hand against him; and he shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren. -Gen 16:12

Islam is a moon-cult made up by the insane murderer/rapist/pedophile/idolater Mohammed (Perdition Be Upon Him) in order to satisfy his carnal desires, not least of which was bloodlust and conquest.

Side: violence
ffemt333(51) Disputed
12 points

no religion is perfect. how many Christians are murderers or rapists or pedophiles?

Side: peace
Tachmonite(36) Disputed
12 points

9 Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind,

10 Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God.

11 And such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God.

1 Cor 6:9-11

Yes, all have fallen short of the Lord (Rom 3:23), save Jesus Christ in whom we are saved (2 Cor. 5:21.) Both the Old and New Testaments make it clear how flawed human beings are in the various people it records, and that we need to repent of our evil ways. Chrstianity, at least, will lead people away from sin instead of towards it.

This is a stark contrast to Islam and its belief in Ismah, or infallibility of their filthy 'prophets' (Matt. 7:15). If their pedophile/rapist/murderer prophet and his goons cannot be criticized, how can Mohammed's (Perdition Be Upon Him) followers possibly put an end to their evil manner of life?

Side: violence
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
11 points

How many founders of Christianity are murderers, rapists, or pedophiles? 0%

How many founders of Islam are murderers, rapists, AND pedophiles 100%

Side: violence
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
8 points

Muslims believe that the creation of everything in the universe was brought into being by God’s sheer command

Side: peace
12 points

There is a clause within the Quran that explains that if a passage contradicts another passage then the one that is newer supersedes the previous. And in the quran the more violent passages almost always come after peacefull ones thus negating them. With the bible christians can cherry pick what they like and at least be somewhat justified in it because the superseding clause doesnt exist. You cannot do that with the quran so anyone who quotes these peacefull passages and claims that islam is peacefull is outright lying.

Side: violence
12 points

All religions are religions of violence. This includes Islam.

The simple existence of religion is a harmful distortion of reality, and it is a supple platform for the more detrimental dispositions of human nature. Notably, though, all religions do also have a potential for including mitigating pacifistic aspects.

Side: violence
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
6 points

Muslims believe that Islam is the complete and universal version of a primordial faith that was revealed before many times throughout the world

Side: peace
1 point

a harmful distortion of reality

You can't mean that. Harmful by whose standard? I'm not even sure what you mean by harmful. You wouldn't say that if you were Muslim. Is reality so easily distorted?

Side: peace
Jace(5222) Disputed
1 point

You can't mean that.

Well, I meant it half a year ago when I wrote it. I still consider religion in all forms to be a distortion of reality. However, others have subsequently presented stronger arguments than yours which have persuaded me to consider the potential functional necessity of religion.

Harmful by whose standard? I'm not even sure what you mean by harmful.

Mine, obviously. I consider most delusions to be more harmful than beneficial. Religion specifically asserts presumption as fact, and defends is assumptions absent and even against objective proof to the contrary. Consequentially, people act not according to what is real but according to the emotional prejudices they are indoctrinated into. Religion lies a foundation uniquely predisposed to ignorance and discrimination, and asserts that foundation as irrefutable on its own merit alone.

You wouldn't say that if you were Muslim.

Obviously. Your point?

Is reality so easily distorted?

Your incredulity alone does not an effective argument make.

Side: violence
11 points

Well lets see, what is the top story on Jihad watch today... Oh this is good...

http://www.jihadwatch.org/2014/05/hamas-to-kids-shoot-all-the-jews

You be the judge...

Side: violence
ffemt333(51) Disputed
13 points

hey. ever heard of the crusades? when Christians went on a rampage murdering every Muslim who stood in their way?

Side: peace
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
13 points

By the way, how does that excuse mass rape and 21st century slavery?

Side: violence
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
11 points

Ever heard of the muslim invasion of the Byzantine empire? The muslim invasion of India? The muslim invasion of Greece? The muslim invasion of Cyprus? The muslim invasion of Spain? Do you think islam spread from Spain to India peacefully?

Imagine 1000 years from now someone criticizing the United States for invading France during World War II. Look at all those poor innocent Germans they killed on the shores of Normandy.....

Do Christians fight wars? Of course they fight wars... And I once saw a hindu man eat a cheeseburger. Take 20 minutes of your life to read what the Bible says and what the Quran says. Take another five minutes to learn about Jesus and another five to learn about the life of Muhammad.

Side: violence
10 points

I will sooner be convinced the Nazis are the political party of peace.

Side: violence
10 points

I am disagree with your opinion about islam is violence because it equal between all of people and there is no diffrent between rich people and poor people.

Side: violence

I opine strictly on the view in regards to Sharia Law that calls for the execution of homosexuals.

Side: violence
-1 points

...........................................................................

Side: violence
15 points

Of course it the religion of peace

and what you hear about Terrorism has nothing to do with Islam

"ALLAH IS THE GREATEST"

Side: peace
john63953(99) Disputed
14 points

Now that's not biased at all .

Side: violence
ffemt333(51) Disputed
13 points

what religion are you? do you live in america? maybe you are the biased one love

Side: peace
Arya30(74) Disputed
14 points

If terrorism has nothing to do with Islam then why do most of the Muslims, the followers of Islam, spread terrorism and violence? And the terrorists who are Muslims generally encourage young Muslims to spread terrorism and destroy the followers of other religion under the name of Allah.

Side: violence
ffemt333(51) Disputed
12 points

through extremisim and brainwashing. and Islams arent the only ones. ever heard of the klu klux klan?

Side: peace
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
10 points

Allahu Akbar can also be taken to mean "Allah is greater"

Woman converts to Islam, "Allah is greater (than Christianity)"

Flying a plane full of people into the ground, "Allah is greater (than these kaffir)"

Firing rockets randomly at Israeli towns full of men women and children "Allah is greater (than the dirty jew spawn)"

Side: violence
john63953(99) Clarified
13 points

Flying a plane full of people into the ground, "Allah is greater (than these kaffir)"

Firing rockets randomly at Israeli towns full of men women and children "Allah is greater (than the dirty Jew spawn)"

They seem very peaceful according to you.

Side: violence
14 points

Of course it the religion of peace

and what you hear about Terrorism has nothing to do with Islam

Side: peace
AngryGenX(463) Disputed
9 points

Muhammad was the original terrorist. He even claimed, "I have been made victorious with terror."

All modern terrorists simply follow in Muhammad the pedophile's footsteps. From Muhammad Atta crashing into the WTC likely reciting the takbir to Abubakar Shekau bragging abducting over 200 schoolgirls and selling them as sex slaves for $12 a head.

Islam is a sex crazed death cult.

Side: violence
ffemt333(51) Disputed
9 points

once again. extremists. not Islam. and terror is used as a weapon by every single religion. not just Islam.

Side: peace
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
6 points

Muhammed is messenger of allah and he is the best man in the world because ha can changed the world

Side: peace
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
8 points

yes karim your opinion is correct , so we are Muslims and we are proud .

Side: violence
13 points

The root of the word Islam, silm, refers to "making peace, being in a mutually peaceful environment, greetings, rescue, safety, being secure, finding peace, reaching salvation and well being or being far from danger, attaining goodness, comfort and favor, keeping away from troubles and disasters, submitting the self and obeying, respect, being far from wrong." Hence Islam is a religion of peace also. But Islam's doctrines and texts have in some cases been associated with violence. Attitudes and laws towards both violence and peace exist within the Islamic tradition.So, we can say that Islam is a religion of peace as well as violence. But we mostly consider Islam as a religion of violence because the followers of Islam are generally seen spreading violence.

Side: peace
13 points

Like most religions it is one of peace and equality its just a group of people who are fucking up for the rest of them. I'm more than 110% certain that the majority who follow Islamic Religion are not planning on killing anyone, causing violence or anything like that, they just want to live the bog standard life with out the small majority fucking shit up for them.

Side: peace
12 points

ever heard of the crusades? when Christians went on a rampage murdering every Muslim who stood in their way?

Side: peace
1 point

The violence of ancient Christians does not prove the peace of ancient Muslims.

Side: violence
11 points

Look guys, im not saying Islam is a religion of peace at all. i chose peace because it is no worse or better than any other religion. all religions. all people are violent and greedy and lustful in nature. and for the record. i am Christian. and i have read a good amount of the Bible. Christianity and Judaism are no more violent than Islam

Side: peace
10 points

there should be some kind of middle ground. but it appears we are about equal my friend. if you must believe Muslims are terrible people because of their religion so be it. just wanted to put in my view. and for some people on this site, there is no need to get personal its a debate site

Side: peace
11 points

no religion is perfect. how many Christians are murderers or rapists or pedophiles?

Side: peace
10 points

Muslims regard the Quran as the literal word of God, as revealed by the Angel Gabriel to the Prophet Muhammad. It contains God's guidance in the form of direct instruction, warnings, parables, and encouragement.

Side: peace
MohamedAli(78) Clarified
7 points

yes quran is the book which allah down it to the messenger (mohamed ) and its the greatest book in our world

Side: violence
9 points

Islam is religion of peace because there are many people of another religions live in the islamic countries and they are so happy

Side: peace
9 points

Those who believe (in the Qur'an), and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures), and the Christians...and (all) who believe in God and the last day and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve." The Qur'an,

Side: peace
mohamedahmed(3) Clarified
6 points

Islam's most fundamental concept is a rigorous monotheism :)

Side: violence
5 points

Islam is religion of peace and i know many muslims they are very peacly

Side: peace