CreateDebate


Debate Info

22
12
Yes No
Debate Score:34
Arguments:20
Total Votes:44
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (10)
 
 No (10)

Debate Creator

3dgR0cka(29) pic



Is Miley Cyrus a good role model for children?

Miley Cyrus.

She is 16 and on a nice little family show, Hannah Montana. She is adored by girls everywhere in America. But she has had a Vanity Fair photoshoot of herself with no top on with only a bedsheet. Her songs have become themed more about dating and less like the "Nobody is Perfect" and "Life is what you make it" stuff. So what do you think...

Good role model?

Or just another out of control celebrity?

 

 

 

Yes

Side Score: 22
VS.

No

Side Score: 12
4 points

Yes. Miley cyrus is being a great rolemoel to kids, showing them that you can achieve your dreams no matter how far you think it is. True, Miley sometimes gets her parents worried by doing silly stuff, but its not like miley's doing it on stage! After all, you have to admit that Miley is always smiling on stage, welcoming and warm. Don't you?

Side: yes
1 point

Miley isn't doing anything inappropiate on stage, so what's wrong?

She is a good role model, indeed (As Hannah Montana, but)

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

Whatever. Miley Cyrus Is Not A Good Role Model. You Call The Silly Stuff That She Does Appropriate Enough To Look Over? No. There Are Dozens Of Photos Out There Of Her In The Shower And Of Her In Her Underwear. And How Do You Know That Her Smiling On Stage Is Not An Act? Besides ... All We've Seen Of Her Private Life Are The Revealing Pictures, (:

Side: No
2 points

no way, miley cyrus is a DISNEY star, a show for young children. Also, she's funny and cool.she dedicated to her job and enjoys it very much too.

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

Just Because She's A Disney Star Doesn't mean She's Not Rotten. Look At Vanessa Hudgens ... She Took Nude Photos That Somehow Surfaced Online And Guess What ... SHE'S A DISNEY STAR! Look At Lindsay Lohan ... She Currently Lives In Rehab ... SHE WAS A DISNEY STAR! Look At Adrienne Bailon ... She Also Took Nude Photos ... SHE WAS A DISNEY STAR! And The Fact That Miley Is A Disney Star Is Even Worse Because The Things She Does Get The Attention Of Young Children.

Side: No
2 points

I think Miley cyrus is a great rolemodel for children. She grew up with such a humble beginning and she shows children that they can achieve their dreams. and kids dont see Miley doing anything innapropriet onscreen so I dont see the problem.

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

Yeah Right. Miley Cyrus Had Her Fame Handed To Her. She Landed Hannah Montana On Her Second Audition. And Yes, Her Racy Photo-Shoot Was Discussed On Screen And Everyone Was Talking About It.

Side: No
2 points

i think miley is a great role model for children. she went out and achieved her dreams and didnt let anything stop her. she grew up as an average kid in the country. she makes mistakes but who doesnt. shes always smiling and she loves her job.

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

Miley Cyrus Did Not Grow Up As An Average Child, Her Dad Is Billy Ray Cyrus. Get Your Facts Straight.

Side: No
2 points

Yes iThink she is Because she has a Bad past, she had no Friends in 6th grade everyone gained up on her and started hating her, but she didn't let that stop her. She tried and Tried to become the next Hannah Montana, she even gave up cheer leading to be on Hannah Montana. She has done cheer sense a young girl, she gave it all up not even convinced she was going to get the job. Miley was lucky to get the role, she is a good role model because she never let anything stop her and she is very successful now.

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

She Did Not Have A Bad Past, She Was Actually Very Popular In Her Middle School Years. She Landed Hannah Montana On Her Second Audition Ever ... Kinda Handed To Her. And She Was 11 When She Started Hannah Montana So She Hadn't Been Doing Cheerleading For A Long Time.

Side: No
1 point

Well, better than most celebrities out there I guess. ... ......

Side: yes

Dating? Sexual liberation? At sixteen? One would think her a healthy western teenager!

Side: yes
JustDeeIt96(6) Disputed
1 point

Haha, Very Funny. The Difference Is That Not All Parents Approve Of It And They Allow Their Children To Watch Hannah Montana. And Miley Cyrus Is Way Worse Than Dating And Sexual Liberation. Taking Racy Pics Of Herself In Her Underwear And Naked Under A T-Shirt In The Shower ... Real Western Teenager Of Her, (:

Side: No
1 point

The Difference Is That Not All Parents Approve Of It

Who gives a fuck what they approve of? They were probably worse when they were young.

Taking Racy Pics Of Herself In Her Underwear And Naked Under A T-Shirt In The Shower ... Real Western Teenager Of Her

Ah, you are upset because nobody ever sent you pictures like that.

Side: yes
1 point

SHE IS! and fyi she apologized for that photo! she is the best! she tought me to stay true to myself and dont care about what others think! she made my life AWESOME! thank you miley!

Side: Yes
2 points

No, she has had a naughty photoshoot, posted pictures of herself in bikinis (very revealing) on the internet.

Side: No
1 point

Definetely Not. Miley Cyrus Doesn't Only Have One Racy Photo, She Has Dozens. One Being An Actual Photo-Shoot And Several That Were Taken Personally By her With A Camera. Miley Is A Horrible Role Model. She Should've Known That When She Signed On To Hannah Montana That She Would Be A Very Big Role Model For Young Girls. These Photos Were Taken Early In Her Career And Were Taken In Her Underwear And One In A Shower. Does Miley Not Think That These Kids Are Going To See Them And Think That Just Because She Does It That It's Okay? Exactly. Because She Is Looked Up To, Girls Are Going To Start Wearing Skimpy Outfits Like She Does And Taking Racy Photos Like She Does. Is It Because Miley Doesn't Care About Her Fans Or Is It Because She's Just A Rebellious Person?

Side: No

I am not currently aware of a single good Hollywood role model. Mel Gibson comes pretty damn close, but not completely.

Side: No
1 point

Miley Cyrus is a talented singer and she does give kids a good message on her shows I'll give her that, but she's been too slutty.

And don't tell me "she's growing up!" because that doesn't give an excuse for her to not still have younger fans to think about.

And FUCK the new disney, bring Mickey back!

Side: No