CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:5
Arguments:5
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Is a fetus the equivalent of a skin cell? (5)

Debate Creator

FredCDobbs(79) pic



Is a fetus the equivalent of a skin cell?

Just a little something that wcforcier said in my debate 'what makes a human human?'.

Add New Argument
1 point

Depends on how long it has developed.

............................................................................

1 point

Well yes and no, it just depends on how fully developed the fetus is. You wouldn't call a fetus just a skin cell after the 1st trimester.

Side: depends
1 point

Of course not.

It's more.

- Quantatively, 1 skin cell is 1 single cell, whereas a fetus is many more cells.

- Qualitatively, both are human, but a fetus has more potential and is unique (the skin cell is from an existing human with his/her DNA, a fetus has its own unique DNA).

Side: No
1 point

Like I said, wcforcier claimed that a skin cell had the same value as a fetus. What an odd, yet sadly quite common, belief.

Side: No
1 point

If the foetus is around sixteen weeks old, it's more than a skin cell, because it has developed some brain tissue.

However, if you're trying to be technical, a foetus is never a skin cell, in equivalence, because it is multicellular. A zygote is closer to a skin cell.

Side: depends