CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
8
Yes No
Debate Score:13
Arguments:12
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (4)
 
 No (7)

Debate Creator

Mangojuice(90) pic



Is all immigration good all of the time?

Yes

Side Score: 5
VS.

No

Side Score: 8
1 point

Is all immigration good all of the time?

Hello M:

Yes.

excon

Side: Yes
LaughingDog(31) Disputed
2 points

Is all immigration good all of the time?

Hello M:

Yes.

So you supported the Nazi invasion and takeover of Poland?

Side: No
excon(15694) Disputed
1 point

So you supported the Nazi invasion and takeover of Poland?

Hello Dog:

Uhhh, no.. In the English I speak, an invasion is NOT immigration...

Being a fellow who believes in a border less world, and being a fellow who believes in FREEDOM, I say again, moving/immigrating to where ever the hell you wanna live on this fine globe, is just fine by me..

excon

Side: Yes
Mangojuice(90) Disputed
1 point

Do you support millions of white people migrating to North Africa?

Side: No
excon(15694) Disputed
1 point

Do you support millions of white people migrating to North Africa?

Hello M:

As I said to another poster, as a person who believes in FREEDOM, I believe everybody should be FREE to live where ever the hell they wanna live..

Ok, I'm guessing that you'll respond with some stupidity like I want everybody to move into my house.. Come on.. You were gonna say that weren't you??

excon

Side: Yes
PinkGremlin(37) Disputed
1 point

Is all immigration good all of the time?

Hello M:

Yes.

Do you support 5 million right wingers moving to Arizona?

Side: No
1 point

Do you support 5 million right wingers moving to Arizona?

Hello Pinky:

Yeah, I KNEW somebody was gonna say something stupid.. You didn't disappoint.

excon

Side: No
Nomoturtle(856) Disputed
1 point

Kinda seems like saying that all the people that come to your house are good all of the time.

Yeah, sure, the people you invite and enter/leave your house respectfully are fine.

But surely the people you invite that rape your wife, kill your kid, steal your things, etc are an issue, even if you invited them.

And surely the people that are uninvited and break into your house and steal your shit are an issue.

As for the people that break into your house and do your chores for you, sure they're good from a utilitarian perspective, but they still should have waited for an invitation; breaking in is in itself a crime.

You must realise that if you advocate for socialist programs, the requirement of having a border is far more important in order to prevent people from taking advantage of them while they don't contribute to sustaining public welfare. You can't just give everyone free stuff, especially other people's stuff, if not on moral grounds then on the reality that you run out of stuff.

Side: No
1 point

Is all immigration good all of the time?

Hello people:

Let's return to earth, shall we??

Smuggling drugs is NOT immigration.

Stealing my house is NOT immigration.

If anybody wants to say more stupid things about immigration, I'll be back..

excon

Side: Yes
1 point

I don't think you've gotten the message that you're the primary one saying stupid things about immigration.

If that person wants to move to the country in which you live and just so happens to want to live in your house, they're still seeking their own life and their own freedom. Something that you supposedly support, despite how little you know about the concept of borders, boundaries, and national sovereignty.

-

If you don't believe in boundaries, or even the simple concept of having borders remain closed in this manner. Then how can you expect someone to respect the concept of you having your own home, and not attempting to take it from you.

Hell given the political climate, we've seen the government move American citizens from their own living areas in places like New Mexico and use it for the housing of newer immigrants. So at any moment the government could just say fuck you, and toss you out of your own home. Despite how rare of an instance this might be.

-

You're also forgetting that these people are looking for new lives and new opportunities. Which means they will take such a job as smuggling, because it will get them the money that they require for that new life. So they are still immigrating here to the states, despite committing a crime in the process.

Side: No
1 point

Not all immigration can be good. If you're importing illegal drugs we don't want that probably. Sure some of the time it could be good, like someone just moving to another country to have a family there that would be fine.

Side: No