CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:12
Arguments:12
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
  (6)

Debate Creator

Logically(191) pic



Is eating meat unethical?

It's not a secret at all that nearly everywhere in the world, animals are mistreated in farms and factories. The only actual argument I see in favor of meat-eating being ethical always has to do with the bible and "God gave us dominion over animals". Not really an argument if your source is about half contradictions. (I'm not a full vegetarian myself, though I've been making strides to limit my meat consumption to primarily fish on occasion while contemplating the morality of meat-eating. Sure; it was essential 100,000 years ago when it was all humans knew of to sustain themselves in terms of proteins, fats and certain nutrients; but to say we need meat now is a bit wobbly.)
Add New Argument
3 points

The argument for meat eating is the fact that you have jagged teeth. Those weren't made fore eating green beans.

2 points

It is unethical, but we are a sociopathic species by nature.

Amarel(5669) Clarified
1 point

We are the only species that cares how our food feels. .

Mingiwuwu(1446) Clarified
1 point

Watch a rape and you will never say that again.

2 points

It's not a secret at all that nearly everywhere in the world, animals are mistreated in farms and factories.

Animal processing factories don’t exist everywhere in the world and it is not self-evident that farms mistreat their animals.

Sure; it was essential 100,000 years ago

It was essential almost everywhere as recently as 100 years ago. It is still essential for a lot of people in the world. The reason that eating meat is ethical is because not eating meat is a luxury.

The notion that eating meat is unethical is an ethnocentric one based on the availability of alternatives provided by globalization and capitalism and the assumption that everyone enjoys the products of modern western circumstances. When people want to stop eating meat but eat fish, it is not based on reason, but emotion derived from the relative evolutionary closeness we have to mammals (which are easily anthropomorphized) as opposed fish.

Antrim(1287) Clarified
2 points

Well said, I'm sure the millions of starving Africans would prefer to die of hunger rather than be unethical.

2 points

Omnivorous species such as homo sapiens eat both meat and other things. Its neither automatically unethical nor automatically ethical, it depends on the situation. For examples:

Killing a rare species of intelligent animal just so you can eat it is probably unethical. But finding a freshly dead example of the same may not be since then you're just making the best out of an already irreversible situation.

Killing and eating a random wild animal is probably unethical, but killing one with a hunting license issued because the species needs culled to avoid overpopulation woes is probably not.

Slaughtering farm animals in cruel and unusual ways is probably unethical, but killing something domesticated for thousands of years and doing it in what is considered by society to be the quickest and most human way to do it is probably not.

And then finally, I want to point out the hyocrisy of advocating eating fish and eggs but spurning meat. Why does a species get a pass just because it doesn't live in the water? Why is it OK to eat the egg but not the chicken born from the egg?

Grenache(6053) Clarified
1 point

A down vote witout added explanation on a meat/vegan debate, is analogous to saying "ooh, yuck" and pushing your vegetables to the side of the plate.

It's ethical to shoot a monkey in the face and eat it's brains if it throws poop at you.

It is ethical to eat a dead horse on the side of the road.

It is ethical to eating the grass fed cow liver.

It is ethical to eat a human if they are Hitler or Donald Trump

It are being eithicael to eaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat an animal that eats other animals

It's unethical to eat meat from factory farms, who rip out the feathers and cut off the beaks of chickens, feed the animals on unnatural diets, keep them in small enclosures etc.

1 point

It’s remarkable really the concerns of people about the ethics of meat eating while they tap their thoughts on the matter up on an I pad or computer made by a half starved wretch in an impoverished third world country , also the jacket , shoes and belt they wear no doubt comes from the beast they think it ethically wrong to devour .......pass the barbecue sauce please

Mingiwuwu(1446) Clarified
1 point

Case in point. :)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))