CreateDebate


Debate Info

10
7
yes no
Debate Score:17
Arguments:17
Total Votes:18
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 yes (10)
 
 no (7)

Debate Creator

MeatDoctor(20) pic



Is it wrong to cut people up and eat them?

Please provide an argument based on scientific facts

yes

Side Score: 10
VS.

no

Side Score: 7
1 point

Please provide an argument based on scientific facts

You are the one who needs to do this. You need to define what you mean by "wrong" and then provide an argument that the "wrong" you have defined exists objectively.

Otherwise please shut up. You're boring and childish.

Side: yes
MeatDoctor(20) Disputed
1 point

But you are the one who thinks morality can be arrived at scientifically though because you don't believe in objective morality but think people can still be moral through reason alone.

Side: no
JamesDD(11) Disputed
1 point

you are the one who thinks morality can be arrived at scientifically

Shut your stupid lying mouth. Nobody is interested.

Side: yes
1 point

He has no morals. He is a liberals Godless deviant.......................................................................................................

Side: yes
seanB(950) Disputed
1 point

Logical reasoning is only one aspect of human psychology/society. Nobody on Earth is driven purely by reason. Emotion, empathy, bonding, the need for safety, the need for security, the drive for justice and fairness, all have significant weight in determining morals, just as much if not more so than pure logical reasoning.

It is almost universally considered wrong to cut people up and eat them for the above reasons. Nobody needs so-called "objective morality" to tell them that.

This dichotomy you present between "objective morality" or "no morality" is ridiculous. For a start, even the "objective morality" you parrot (I would assume of the Christian variety), is subject to you CHOOSING to believe in it.

Side: yes
1 point

We need more details.

Did they ask to be cut up?

Are they alive when you are cutting?

What is the situation that brings this about? (starvation, just for funziez?)

Define "wrong" in this context.

Side: yes
No arguments found. Add one!