CreateDebate


Debate Info

10
28
Yes No..of course not
Debate Score:38
Arguments:21
Total Votes:47
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (10)
 
 No..of course not (12)

Debate Creator

Soldier55(55) pic



Is legalizing prostitution a way to reduce rapes?

Yes

Side Score: 10
VS.

No..of course not

Side Score: 28
1 point

It is because sex workers would not be reluctant to report rapes against them as they are now,

Side: Yes
4 points

Sexual gratification is only gained by the rapist through the violent act of fear and control they induce in their victim. A willing and paid participant would not satisfy their perverse need and in no way would effect a reduction of rape victims.

Side: No..of course not
Pantagruel(984) Disputed
1 point

I'm calling typical feminist bullshit on that one.

Sexual gratification is only gained by the rapist through the violent act of fear and control they induce in their victim.

What a massive generalization. Simply astonishing. Titanic-sized, really, and just as ill-fated.

First off, there's this thing called statutory rape, which isn't really rape in the literal sense of the term, and is often fully consensual, simply not with somebody of legal age. This can be pure, loving sexuality.

Then, of course, there are female rapists. Do they also rape exclusively for violent reasons?

Alcohol and other intoxicants are frequently a cause [single among many] of rape.

Most rapists are not exclusively aroused by rape, and are just as likely (nay, if not more!) to engage in consensual sex; this seems to me to be quite the knife in the back of your hypothesis.

A willing and paid participant would not satisfy their perverse need and in no way would effect a reduction of rape victims.

Ease of access in times of horniness and drunkenness which would otherwise result in a stranger rape may very well result, instead, in a paid, consensual encounter.

Besides, I've read that some 1/3 of men have admitted in a survey that, under the right circumstances, they would rape. I find it rather far-fetched to suggest that the only reason one-third of all men who would rape would rape only for violent fetishistic motives.

Side: Yes
RavenLily(733) Disputed
4 points

I'm not a feminist, so I'm calling bullshit on your bullshit. Using the word only was a mistake on my part, as I'm sure there are other triggers other than the ones I referred to that drive one to rape. And of course, it goes without saying, this debate was not intended to refer to statutory rape, duh... How ridiculous that you even brought that into the scenario. But even that is not as ridiculous as your other statement:

Most rapists are not exclusively aroused by rape, and are just as likely (nay, if not more!) to engage in consensual sex; this seems to me to be quite the knife in the back of your hypothesis. If this is the case, why not just restrict sexual activity to that which is consensual?? Why bother to rape?? The knife in the back you refer to seems more accurately to be the foot in your mouth.

Side: No..of course not
0 points

This is also true, I believe.

Great point.

As a woman, I am wondering if you would care to expound or confirm or deny on my earlier claim that the #1 sexual fantasy among women is rape. Gang rape, to be more specific.

I can post links that cite surveys that confirm this, is you wish.

Thanks!

Side: No..of course not
RavenLily(733) Clarified
5 points

Sorry, but no, I don't care to expound, confirm or deny your claims of sexual fantasies among women regarding rape... You seem a little too eager to hear them. :))

Side: Yes
1 point

Rape is about violence and control, not sex. And even in those places where prostitution is illegal it really isn't that hard to find someone to have sex with (including a prostitute). People don't rape because they're horny. They rape because they're predatory.

Side: No..of course not
1 point

Thank you! Not many people really recognize the psychology behind rapes. Rape isn't about sex, it's about being in charge.

If anything, I think that legalizing prostitution might actually [i]increase[/i] rape rates, because it would provide a larger number of women who are looked down upon by society, and would be viewed by psychopaths as "acceptable" targets.

Side: No..of course not

Possibly, but the number of rapes it could possibly reduce would be incredibly small, since rape is almost never about sexual satisfaction.

Side: No..of course not
1 point

Also, since rape is just as much of a crime as hiring a prostitute, anyone raping for sexual satisfaction can just get a hooker illegally now.

Side: No..of course not
1 point

I think legalizing prostitution can only increase problems in society....Human Trafficking would increase.......

Side: No..of course not
0 points

No it is not.

I do feel that prostitution should be legalized, however.

But if it were--and one day it indeed will be--I highly doubt we will see much of a decline in the nation's rapes.

Most guys who buy whores are not the rapist type.

True rape is more rare than you think anyway.

A lot of times the case is false. The woman just got pissed for some reason at the dude and decided to file charges.

The vast majority of rapes are committed by men whom the woman knows. And sometimes have been intimate with.

I wish rape was legal here.

Not violent rape. No assault and battery.

But if a hot woman is walking around wearing almost nothing, she shouls be fair game.

Remember Suddam Hussein's boys? Uday and Koosay or whatever their names were?

I heard they had rape squads.

They would be in public and see a hot chick and have thier thugs go abduct the women and take them back to their palace. Then the boys would do the women, and not hurt them, just screw them. Even feed them and give them expensive drugs or liquor!

Then they would return them unharmed back to the public.

What's so bad about this? The women got to have orgasms, good food and drink? Sex with a powerful celebrity.

I am sure many of the women enjoyed it.

Did you know that most women's #1 fantasy is rape?

Research it yourself if you do not believe me.

I would like to have a squad in a van at my disposal like Uday and Kusay did. Just for fun.

I am sure that on some planets where there is intelligent life--there are millions, BTW--that rape of this sort is legal. You could just throw somebody down on the sidewalk and go for it.

Why cannot Earth be like that?

America is too puritanical.

Life is unfair.

LOL

Side: No..of course not
Soldier55(55) Disputed
1 point

Can u kindly tell me what are true rapes???I have also heard cases where women charge false allegations on men but all women are not same.

.one can't judge all women by just looking at 10-20 women living around....women live all over the world for eg-in India earlier widows were blamed for death of their husbands...as if they had murdered their husbands.i this sort of society can u expect that all women can dare to charge false allegations on their rapists...here condition is so bad that the society blames a women for her rape more than her rapist...And not only HOT CHICKS get raped even 2 months old baby girl and 97 yrs old woman was raped..

Side: Yes
Soldier55(55) Disputed
1 point

Can u kindly tell me what are true rapes???I have also heard cases where women charge false allegations on men but all women are not same.

.one can't judge all women by just looking at 10-20 women living around....women live all over the world for eg-in India earlier widows were blamed for death of their husbands...as if they had murdered their husbands.i this sort of society can u expect that all women can dare to charge false allegations on their rapists...here condition is so bad that the society blames a women for her rape more than her rapist...And not only HOT CHICKS get raped even 2 months old baby girl and 97 yrs old woman was raped..

Side: Yes
0 points

No one asks to be raped.............................................................................................................

Side: No..of course not
Atrag(5666) Disputed
1 point

Well done for missing the point. .

Side: Yes