CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:16
Arguments:14
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Is there a test for goodness? (13)

Debate Creator

Nebeling(1117) pic



Is there a test for goodness?

Add New Argument
2 points

Goodness is up to an individual's own personal interpretation of what is good... so I guess an individual might have their own personal test but that wouldn't apply to everyone else. So... yeah... whatevs.

Nebeling(1117) Clarified
1 point

Goodness is up to an individual's own personal interpretation of what is good

It's true that people tend to differ in how they judge what is good. Would you rather say that all interpretations are arbitrary and carry no truth value, or that some interpretations are more true than others?

1 point

If you set a standard for the 'goodness' then you can make one as easily as forming a checklist.

Yes. Is my life helping other people is how I know I'm good. .

goodmale(1459) Disputed
1 point

you can tell people that there is no real overpopulation of dogs or cats only humans

1 point

I make my self have a good heart. I don't care if I like it or not I just make my self whats right. I want to jogg black people. But I don't jogg them because I make my self think that they are no different then white. no matter of all the mad things I think of them I make my self like them because that who I am I think wrong but I make my self good. I don't care if I like it or not I make my self good. please don't call me racist. I try not to think that way

1 point

Would you kick a puppy, a kitten or a baby? If the answer is "yes", then you are not good.

Nebeling(1117) Disputed
2 points

What if the kitten is attacking the pilot in a flying airplane, and in order to save everyone (including the kitten itself) you have to kick it?

GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
2 points

Well, first off... that pilot has bigger problems if he can't defend himself from a kitten.

Second, why would you have to kick it? Is the kitten attacking the pilot's leg? You could easily just pick the kitten up and remove it from the cockpit.

You could always call Samuel L. Jackson... "I've had it with these motherfuckin' kittens on this motherfuckin' plane!"

dropigy(230) Disputed
1 point

what if the kitten is tearing a mouse to shreds slowly and painfully and a pussy is tearing that kitten to shreds and a baby is using a knife to cut the dog's tail off and the only thing you can do to solve the situation is kick the dog.

GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
1 point

Grab the baby, yank the knife from his hand, then pick up the dog and the cat and leave the kitten and the mouse alone.

1 point

There are many tests for goodness, but none of them mean anything because the concept itself is meaningless by virtue of its innate subjectivity.