CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:40
Arguments:28
Total Votes:44
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Is there any universal truth? (28)

Debate Creator

Prometheus(23) pic



Is there any universal truth?

?

-PromÊtheus

Add New Argument

matter exists.......................................................................................

Are you speaking onto the entire universe we currently know of or are you speaking on a universal truth here on the planet earth?

Prometheus(23) Disputed
3 points

Well universally of course. But can you say that matter does exist? Science is constantly changing. Right now you can say matter exist, but Universally as in all periods of time, no. Matter may not exist in some unknown way.

JakeJ(3255) Disputed
2 points

You are thinking too much.

Matter exists. I'm not saying it will always, or that it always has existed but it does in fact exist.

Quit trying to be so deep and get some common sense.

Being deep is over rated.

I see that as the easy rout, anyone can be like: "oh, well how do you know anything exists, what really matters....."

Get real and do what is best for your future.

Side: Being deep is over rated
2 points

If you argue on that level then their is no possibility of any universal truth. Time cannot be used to argue universality because you cannot argue that time is universal either. Do you understand what I mean? I sometimes have problems being eloquent with my explanations.

Side: Being deep is over rated
Ledfoot(133) Disputed
1 point

Thats fricken Deep man. I would say no ''''''''''''''''''''''''

Side: No there is not
2 points

Is your question the antithesis of: Is there any universal falsity?

The existence of a universal truth? It depends what you are denoting or connoting in your usage of the term "universal truth".

Are you using the term "universal" as contrary to "particular" truth?

All men die; this is true, universally. There is no exception that one man will not die.

Side: Uncertainty of authors use
Prometheus(23) Disputed
2 points

Yes, you have pretty much hit the nail on the head for a definition. But can you say with full vindication that every man will die? You never know what things are unknown? I'm not necessarily saying your right or wrong, I am just stating arguments to keep people thinking. Its a hard question no person has been able to answer for thousands of years, and most likely will never be able to answer, but it is fun to ponder.

Side: Still unanswered
lawnman(1106) Disputed
2 points

The statement: all men die, is a self-evident statement. The statement needs no proof because its truth is obvious. Now, lets convert that statement into a self-evident proposition; all men are mortal. The proposition is an axiom, meaning its truth is obvious and no proof is necessary.

The vindicability of the proposition is as obvious as the axiom itself. Any argument that contradicts the axiom is an argumentum ad speculum and is not vindicable; for the argument of speculation is absent any evidence that is axiomatic.

The proposition will remain an axiom until a contradictory axiom is revealed. That is a universal truth.

The contradiction being of course; Some men are mortal.

Side: Axiomatic
xaeon(1093) Disputed
1 point

"All men die; this is true, universally. There is no exception that one man will not die."

Actually, that isn't exactly true. Seven percent of all of the humans who have ever lived are still alive, and amongst them may be the man who never dies.

Side: Axiomatic
1 point

Perhaps, but I nor any other man or woman shall live long enough to verify that possibility. The mortal man can not bare witness of immortality. The mortal man can certainly bare witness of the long-lived man, but never the immortal man.

If there is a man among us who shall never die, the same could not truthfully be called a man.

Side: Axiomatic
1 point

Truth is universal by definition. The only way we can know Truth about anything is to know Truth about related things as well... everything in existence is related. Truth is absolute knowledge that we will never know.

Side: Truth is universal

Maybe the universal truth is that there is not universal truth. ;)

Side: Truth is universal
1 point

Lets start with this. To assert that something is true is to say that something is definite, unchanging, or completely self-consistant. So, to ask the question is there a universal truth is really asking is there something in the universe that is true. To answer this question we must not accept any bias whether it is religious or none religious. So i our assumtion is that anything is possible but then if anything is possible we also assume the possiblity that nothing is possible. Ultimately this statement cannot be true because if anything is possible that would mean it is possible for something and nothing to be possible at the same time which clearly contradict the whole idea in its' self. The answer is that only somethings are possible because nothing cannot exist no matter how you try to make sense of the idea its' just simply impossible. So there you have the final answer to your question. Only something can exist and nothing cannot that is a universal truth. So universal truths do exist.

Side: Truth is universal
1 point

The universal truth is that the truth is universal.

It is what it is

Side: Truth is universal

I don't know what you mean, buddy --------------------------------

Side: Truth is universal
Bradf0rd(1428) Disputed
1 point

You know what's funny? That you get a point putting this null comment here and I get docked a point for hiding it from people when really I'm probably do you a favor.

facepalm.jpg

Side: Truth is universal