CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:26
Arguments:21
Total Votes:28
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Is this appropriate in a classroom? (18)

Debate Creator

BlueEyed15(140) pic



Is this appropriate in a classroom?

In a drama class one afternoon, a teacher started a game where the class was meant to line up in a line. He/she said that one by one they had to fall forward and pretend to die in some funny way (in a minute). Music played while it was done.

 

Is this appropriate in any classroom? Does it go against morals to represent a horrible thing in an amusing way?

Add New Argument

Well death is a part of life. It is appropriate but its a pretty pointless activity. Drama should be scrapped as a subject. If any kids from the UK are here whatever you do don't do GCSE Drama; it's a piece of shit.

1 point

I agree, it should either be optional or just taken out. I guess the scenario is okay as long as it was optional in case anyone was being offended.

2 points

Well it is a drama class and not real. You learn this because if you want to get into acting you need to learn how to fake die. It is completely appropriate for your learning.

1 point

well it is a drama class and the point of a drama class is to learn acting.

BlueEyed15(140) Disputed
1 point

well it is a drama class and the point of a drama class is to learn acting.

I don't think "the point" should allow you to conduct death games. Although drama classes are meant to be fun and informative, it makes death seem like one.

Cartman(18192) Disputed
3 points

It doesn't make death a game, it makes drama a game.

Cuaroc(8829) Disputed
1 point

Again it's a Drama class you're meant to act and those "death games" are just one way of doing it.

1 point

When we were children we used to play ''cowboys and Indians'' ( sorry, but somehow cowboys and Native Americans doesn't sound the same.) in the streets of Belfast and sometimes incorporate the game; ''who can die the best''. Holding our stomachs, twisting and turning, then hitting the ground after about 5 minuets of over dramatic moaning and groaning, it was great fun. Later on these dramatic rehearsals proved to be most useful.

You're (Northern) Irish? Well that explains a lot. I bet you support the crappy DUP or something.

1 point

I don't think it was meant to be called a game nor the teacher meaning that at all. I think the point of calling it a game was just to spark an activity. But really, if you're just acting like your dying and not getting killed literally, I don't think there's anything wrong with it. That's basically what drama class is for. You gotta know how to act. If your teacher can't teach you how to die "realistically" in drama class then I think there is a problem with that. I guess the point of dying in a "funny" way was to enhance skills in a comedic side and not a serious situation.