CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:7
Arguments:6
Total Votes:7
Ended:10/31/08
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
  (6)

Debate Creator

Kuklapolitan(4313) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Jennifer Hudson's Mother, Brother Dead & Nephew Still Missing!

An American Idol's Nightmare

One of my all time favorite American Idol's and Oscar winner Jennifer Hudson is living a nightmare beyond belief this week-end and for months to come by the shooting deaths of her beloved mother and brother on Friday last (10-24). Since then her 7 year old nephew, Julian King, has been missing and there has been no word from anyone of his whereabouts. I'd like to know what your take is on this tragedy and whether or not YOU believe Julian will be found alive. What do you think the motivation could have been for this person to commit such heinous crimes?


Add New Argument
2 points

Sooo sad- I can't imagine. He's just a little boy. This is when the death penalty actually seems kind.

Oh Jamaise...I am inordinately saddened by this tragedy. I just wish I could reach out and hold that poor girl. You know I'm not a death penalty person but I surely could understand it if someone in that family blew the brains out of the person who did this. But how sick is this....how sick is he? Crime of passion? Who knows...I just feel sickened inside.

It is now 9:00 PM EST where I live and unless they're keeping everything a deep dark secret, no one has heard anything about this poor young man since Friday. Whoever perpetrated this terrible and mind-shattering event has also taken Julian King, 7 years old, away...or has taken him somewhere and done away with him! It's unthinkable that something like this can happen in a family but it does...all too often. Jennifer has offered a $100,000.00 reward for any information.

I have the queerest feeling in the pit of my stomach that Julian King will not be found for some time. I hope I am wrong for what does a 7 year old boy know of anything that has happened in that tragic family? But now he was probably the only witness to the slayings and knows all too well who did this! Neighbors have stated that all was not well within the family and it was troubled. I cannot believe this was a random shooting but you never know!

While the troubled family issue bears looking at closely, is it possible that someone in the neighborhood, a friend perhaps, may have thought because of Jennifer's success there might be money there? The neighborhood was not a good one so I have heard...it was the South Side and the family didn't wish to move. Jennifer may have just been there on Thursday to celebrate her sister's 31st birthday! Was it money or was it family strife? Will Julian be found alive? What do you think?

Side: My Prayers are with you Jennifer

My gut feelings never fail me...I had wished for something entirely different but it is what it is, I'm so sorry Jennifer.

Supporting Evidence: THIS IS PROBABLY JULIAN (news.yahoo.com)
Side: My Prayers are with you Jennifer

This afternoon the terrible news came. Julian King has been found dead in the back seat of Jason Hudson's car found on a Chicago street on the West Side. Jason Hudson is the brother of Jennifer Hudson, who was slain last Friday along with his mother in their Chicago home. Jennifer Hudson made her last trip to the morgue this afternoon to identify the boy's remains. It was reported that he had been shot several times. William Balfour is still being detained at this time and is the estranged husband of Julia Hudson, Jennifer's sister.

Supporting Evidence: Story From E! On-Line (www.eonline.com)
Side: And what now shall pass
1 point

I know I just can't imagine. The only things I kill are flies and mosquitoes and even then I'm aware I've just killed something. To kill a human? A child? What kind of person has that ability?

Side: And what now shall pass