Debate Info

Kinect Move
Debate Score:18
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 Kinect (4)
 Move (1)

Debate Creator

Drewseph(5) pic

Kinect vs Move

Ever since Nintendo created the Wii, Microsoft and Sony have been trying to come up with a new and better motion-controlled device. Now they have the Xbox Kinect and the PlayStation Move. One requires no hands but is innacurate, while the the other one requires controllers but is a lot more accurate. Although, the other one, the Move, some people may see it as a copycat of the Wii.


You decide which one is better!!! Tongue out


Side Score: 17


Side Score: 1
5 points

If you're going to have a feature based off of movement or freedom, it's most favorable to remove any tethers such as a controller or wand or wiimote or whatever. If the kinect can be strengthened in function, imagine what will come out of it's coupling with the rise of 3D television.

Side: kinect
5 points

Move is just a rip-off from the Wii remote. Kinect is actually a step-up from both.

Side: kinect
4 points

Kinect Is definitely better than move. With the Move you need to use a controller, but with the Kinect you are the controller. can you drink something while playing the Move without sitting the controllers down? NO!!!

Side: kinect
3 points

kinect opens a world of possibilites. not to mention the apps with kinect, not just games. (videokinect, zune, avatar kinect coming soon)

Side: kinect
-1 points

I'm pretty neutral, but if you're going for accuracy, I'd say the Move would be the better option...

Side: move