CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
3
Decreases Suffering Is Too Authoritarian
Debate Score:9
Arguments:12
Total Votes:10
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Decreases Suffering (4)
 
 Is Too Authoritarian (3)

Debate Creator

Slavedevice(1393) pic



License To Parent

Not always, but most of the time good parents raise a very responsible child.  Poor parents usually raise kids that are not very successful (and maybe even criminals). We don’t think it’s a violation of rights to require licenses for almost anything that involves the public (driving, occupational,even MARRIAGE!).  So, why is it ludicrous to require a simple license (got a job, not a criminal) to reproduce?!

Decreases Suffering

Side Score: 6
VS.

Is Too Authoritarian

Side Score: 3
1 point

So, why is it ludicrous to require a simple license (got a job, not a criminal) to reproduce?!

Hello Nazi:

If the world gave out licenses to reproduce, Nazis wouldn't get one.

excon

PS> Lest you DENY that you're a Nazi, I'm referring my friends HERE..

https://www.createdebate.com/conversations/follow/excon/Slavedevice

Side: Decreases Suffering

Good point. Allegedly Adolf Hitler and others had severe health problems.

Side: Decreases Suffering
DrChamberlin(145) Clarified
1 point

Seeing as the topic is based on the aspect of personal responsibility and not race. You're just revealing how weak your side of the argument is. By just going out of your way to flatly call someone a Nazi.

How about I refer to you as Pedo from now on?

Side: Decreases Suffering
Slavedevice(1393) Clarified
1 point

He has a reason to call me a Nazi lmmfao! I am very interested in the Nazis but I cut short of Killn Jews . I am very very Authoritarian. I believe a lot of freedom causes more pain than strict order. And I do think genetic engineering, etc would make a better stronger mankind.

Side: Decreases Suffering
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

You're just revealing how weak your side of the argument is. By just going out of your way to flatly call someone a Nazi.

Hello again, Dr:

Weak?? WEAK??? WEAK??? Dude! Can you fucking READ???

https://www.createdebate.com/conversations/follow/excon/Slavedevice

excon

Side: Is Too Authoritarian

Unfortunately, as things are going right now. Such a choice would be a bit too far for our society to accept. We are built strongly on personal freedoms and the moment you legalize, or at least request that such behaviors as simply having children, be allowed by the state. Then you begin to tread on some rather dangerous ground.

Doing as such would allow for other measure to come into place down the line, that could only cause more problems for the populace. Social engineering doesn't even begin to cover it at this point.

-

Yould then argue that those people with poor credit are not allowed to have children, then you could eventually adjust it to those who do not possess the best amount of social standing, and so on.

Side: Is Too Authoritarian