CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
8
Agree Shut up you wrinkly old fart
Debate Score:10
Arguments:9
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (2)
 
 Shut up you wrinkly old fart (7)

Debate Creator

Factology(405) pic



Man cannot think or reason

Agree

Side Score: 2
VS.

Shut up you wrinkly old fart

Side Score: 8
No arguments found. Add one!
2 points

He is very simply talking about determinism and causality of any given thought. He's right, it's always a chain reaction and seeing cows upside down may have inspired the accidental chain of events that led to the camera being invented, so on and so forth but every person (even those who don't invent) thinks and reasons.

Where he may have a point is that the 'thought and reasoning' is simply luck of having the life events and DNA we have as opposed to any 'I got this thought myself' kind of thing since you are your brain, on a mental level.

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart
1 point

@Mingiwuwu

Thank you for not saying something retarded. When Jacque says man cannot think or reason he doesn't mean it in a completely literal sense, "reason" is a learned method of arriving at rational conclusions and without learning the proper methodology the human brain has no ability to discern the logical from the illogical. Therefor man cannot think because your egoistic "self" does not produce or control your thoughts and man cannot reason because reason is a methodology rather than a property of the mind.

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart

The guy seems to have hit meth prior to the interview

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart
1 point

Is there some reference to yourself here !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart
1 point

Are you referring to Fresco ? I agree reason seems to be an alien concept to this idiotic creature who thinks himself a modern day guru of sorts , it’s not surprising you parrot this prize clowns bullsit ad nauseum .

You posted up an ill advised debate topic on this clown in the past and I destroyed it yet here you go again , do you have any thoughts of your own ever ? You don’t seem to have any thoughts of your own you just parrot the “opinions “ of this idiot like the crawling sycophants you are

You can now do your usual by banning and multiple downvoting

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart
Amarel(5669) Banned
0 points

Man cannot think or reason

Said the man without thought or reason.

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart
Factology(405) Disputed
1 point

Said the man without thought or reason.

What makes you think you're smarter than inventor, engineer, social philosopher and futurist Jacque Fresco? You are just an ignoramus who doesn't want to admit that man cannot think or reason or have free will because it feels bad for your little feefees and thus you cannot accept science. All of your thoughts and opinions are manifestations of electrical and chemical mechanics which are beyond your control and reflections of your environment.

Side: Agree
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Are you the intelligent ignoramus here ???????????

Tell us about control and reflections of your environment !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Shut up you wrinkly old fart