CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
9
Marijuana Tabacco
Debate Score:20
Arguments:11
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Marijuana (6)
 
 Tabacco (5)

Debate Creator

Libavius(114) pic



Marijuana vs Tabacco

Which is worse health-wise?

 

Marijuana

Side Score: 11
VS.

Tabacco

Side Score: 9
No arguments found. Add one!
4 points

Tobacco is much worse simply based on the amount consumed... if they were consumed equally, I suspect marijuana would be worse because there is no filter.

Side: Tabacco
casper3912(1581) Disputed
2 points

It depends on how they are consumed as well, vaporizers are better than smoking.

Side: Tabacco
3 points

Interesting... I wasn't aware of such devices.... I had to Google it. Good point.

Side: Marijuana
xerin(12) Disputed
2 points

Even if they were consumed in the same amount, and even without being filtered, i would still expect tobacco to be more damaging simply do to the toxic cornucopia of additives found in cigarettes.

Side: Marijuana
Cinderella99(6) Disputed
1 point

Oddly enough, the National Cancer Institute has recognized the cancer-fighting properties of cannabis. I'm sure they have also recognized the cancer-causing effects of tobacco.

Not to mention the fact that tobacco restricts your cardiovascular system and cannabis does the opposite. And that tobacco can cause serious health risks to pregnant mothers and there is no evidence to support any adverse effects of cannbis on a fetus. Also, tobacco is one of the top causes of death in America while cannabis has never caused a single recorded death EVER.

I can cite my sources if anyone is interested. :)

Side: Tabacco
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

You would be correct if it were not for the carcinogens and other as yet unknown chemicals cigarettes add. Tobacco by itself probably isn't any worse than smoking any other plant. Probably tastes like shit though.

Side: Marijuana
2 points

Results from a study in 2007 can guide your question. See the link.

Original article title: Development of a rational scale to assess the harm of drugs of potential misuse

Supporting Evidence: a chart from a study on drugs (i52.tinypic.com)
Side: Tabacco
1 point

Tobacco is worse because of the nicotine and chemicals in cigarettes. Marijuana supposedly doesn't cause emphysema or cancer, but can cause Asthma or bronchitis. Marijuana also has benefits to cancer patients, glaucoma, and Alzheimer's Disease.

Side: Tabacco
Cinderella99(6) Disputed
2 points

but can cause Asthma

Hey, just thought I should point out that my doctor recommended I use marijuana with a vaporiser to possibly cure my asthma in the long run! I have noticed significant benefits from it already. :)

Side: Marijuana
1 point

Marijuana is better for you than tobacco, beer, and greasy food.

There is no logical reason it should be illegal for anyone over 18.

I however prefer alcohol. Marijuana tends to make me paranoid, I have no calamities which it cures, and when I get fucked up I want to at least have to pay for it in the morning.

Side: Tabacco
1 point

Hmm, well actually Marijuana is smoked with tobacco so, naughty..!

But if you have a pure marijuana cigarette and a normal one, the normal one will contain far more harmful chemicals.

Marihuana has killed only 1 person due to an overdose in the UK in records, but far more people due to tobacco.

Side: Tabacco