CreateDebate


Debate Info

21
20
I agree. I disagree.
Debate Score:41
Arguments:26
Total Votes:43
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 I agree. (8)
 
 I disagree. (12)

Debate Creator

Sitara(11089) pic



More than one person can share an idea. Logic does not belong to one person only.

I agree.

Side Score: 21
VS.

I disagree.

Side Score: 20

There are no original ideas. There's nothing new under the sun. Your ideas have been bought sold and bought again. Accept that.

Side: I agree.
2 points

Of course, logic belongs to everybody.

But the idea belongs to the person who came up with it, that is pure logic to me.

Side: I disagree.
Sitara(11089) Disputed
1 point

no, one person does not own logic. You need to stop. I did not make that idea up, and I do NOT remember where i got it or who said it first. Logic cannot be copyrighted because it belongs to everyone.

Side: I agree.
shoutoutloud(4182) Disputed Banned
3 points

one person does not own logic.

When did I say one person owns logic?

I quote myself; '' of course, logic belongs to everybody ''

Logic cannot be copyrighted because it belongs to everyone.

Dana, are you seriously saying that logic and ideas are the same thing?

Because you are wrong. Logic is one thing, idea is another. You can even have an idea without logic.

I'm just saying, that IF YOU INVENT SOMETHING, the idea is YOURS, not anybody else's.

Side: I disagree.
shoutoutloud(4182) Disputed Banned
3 points

Lol, seriously Dana?

We have a minor disagreement and you declare me your enemy? You are a confused soul, aren't ya?

Side: I disagree.
PhotonDragon(217) Disputed Banned
1 point

Dana, you seem to be a tad bit puzzled on the words idea and logic.

Logic: The study of the principles of reasoning, especially of the structure of propositions as distinguished from their content and of method and validity in deductive reasoning.

Idea: Something, such as a thought or conception, that potentially or actually exists in the mind as a product of mental activity.

These are two different things. An idea can be held by one person and be oatented bu one person. Logic is just reasoning which nobody can truly own.

Side: I disagree.
2 points

Logic belongs to everyone but an idea belongs to one person it only belongs to multitudes if that person is willing to share it. Otherwise it is copyright.

Side: I disagree.
Sitara(11089) Disputed
1 point

I did not steal anything. .

Side: I agree.
Vermink(1944) Clarified
2 points

Wasn't saying you did :P

Side: I agree.
2 points

As I told Srom long ago... it's perfectly fine to post content for debate that you didn't author.... simply post a link to where the content came from or name the author otherwise it looks like you tried to pass it off as your own when that wasn't really your intention.

Side: I disagree.
1 point

Fair enough. I tried to get her to reveal the source of my argument so I could do so, but...

Side: I disagree.

Sure, logic can belong to everyone and shared, but I can't take credit for the Austrian Business Cycle Theory, that is Ludwig von Mises.

Side: I disagree.
Sitara(11089) Clarified
1 point

Love, I would gladly reveal my source if I knew who he she was. Y'all are acting like I am selling nuclear weapons secrets.

Side: I agree.