CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
1
Nationalize Privatize
Debate Score:2
Arguments:2
Total Votes:2
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Nationalize (1)
 
 Privatize (1)

Debate Creator

skyfish(276) pic



Nationalize the Natural Gas Pipeline System

The pipeline system that delivers natural gas to utiltiy companies is a patchwork of private/public infrastrucrue which is ineffient and needs upgradnig. If NG is going to be the "transiton" fuel to renewable energy, should we, as a country, decide how best it should be optimized for the public good... or should we leave to a handful of oligarch's to wrestle over while our planet burns?

 

 

In an ideal world, our electricity system would run on 100 percent clean, renewable energy.

 

To do that, we have to balance the intermittency of renewables with our steady need for electricity. That’s where natural gas comes in...

 

Many policymakers, regulators and industry members believe we have to build thousands of miles of new pipelines...

 

Nationally, the U.S. has plenty of existing pipeline infrastructure to accommodate significantly expanded gas use...

 

Although we will  need to build out new pipes to fill in certain gaps, this should be complemented by an emphasis on  removing the regulatory and market barriers that keep us from making much more efficient use of the massive infrastructure that’s in place today.

 

If we don’t, then billions of dollars of capital sunk into new pipelines will fall needlessly on ratepayer shoulders, and potentially constrain the ongoing expansion of  clean, low-cost renewable technologies.

 

To be beneficial for clean energy, gas must be used efficiently and with a limited role into the future.

 

http://www.forbes.com/sites/edfenergyexchange/2015/06/05/how-to-ensure-new-natural-gas-infrastructure-doesnt-lock-out-renewables/

 

 

This Forbes article makes a strong case for nationalizing the NG pipeline system in this country.... wouldn't you agree?

 

 

Nationalize

Side Score: 1
VS.

Privatize

Side Score: 1
No arguments found. Add one!
1 point

You must be very young or have a bad memory. All nationalized industries, well in the U.K, at any rate, were a total disaster. From the ''puff-puff' railway network, to the 'jungle drums' telephone system the government run utilities were falling back into third world status. Civil servants are not business executives and under the the stagnation of their eye watering, incompetent mismanagement so many British industries fell too far behind for the taxpayer to finance their upgrading. Private money and expertise have brought most utilities back into the 21st century.

Side: Privatize
skyfish(276) Disputed
1 point

you mean like how the trains used to run on time and you could go from one end of london to the other without having to buy another ticket?

but now you have to change "companies" several times to make the same trip?

you mean like THAT kind of more "efficient"?

Side: Nationalize