CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
3
Nightwing Red Hood
Debate Score:9
Arguments:6
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Nightwing (4)
 
 Red Hood (2)

Debate Creator

marakobib(57) pic



Nightwing vs Red Hood

dick grayson(nightwing) or jason todd(red hood)

Nightwing

Side Score: 6
VS.

Red Hood

Side Score: 3
2 points

Nightwing used to be Robin but he got trained by Batman so I think that Nightwing would win because if he has Batman's tactics then he would win.

Side: Nightwing
1 point

Nightwing has more experience and is the best robin

He is also less reckless and has beat him before

GO NIGHTWING!!!

Side: Nightwing
1 point

I think that Nightwing has more experience. However, their rivalry has to be one of the best, even if I love reading brother moments between them in fanfiction.

They're just all around more evenly matched, let's take a look, shall we?

Strength: Jason

Acrobatics: Dick (Obviously :P)

Traps: Jason

Book-smarts: Dick

Most everything else is a tie, or irrelevant.

Also, Dick has defeated Jason in their past encounter. I say Jason can beat everyone else (besides Bruce, Cass, and maybe Babs), but due to their similarities, we have to look for more experience, and that's Dick over Jason.

I love them both, and the fight could change drastically depending on the situation.

Side: Nightwing
1 point

Nightwing was raped by Tarantula. XD

It says so in here: http://www.cracked.com/article_19786_the-6-creepiest-sexual-encounters-in-comic-book-history_p2.html

(It's on number 2#)

I don't think a guy who is some girl's bitch could face Red Hood like that.

Side: Red Hood
0 points

well I guess I'll give the point to Red Hood. But Red Robin or Tim Drake is the best Robin of all time. Let's look at the facts, 1. Tim Drake figured out Batman's identity (albeit in kind of a weird way but whatever he's the only person in Gotham to figure it out). 2. "Come on Batman... where are the pants?" First Robin to not where a bikini bottom as part of his costume. 3. Owned the entire discography of Depeche Mode. The guy followed Bruce's steps around the world investigating this massive conspiracy when everyone else threw in the towel. He's the first Robin with his own mobile, and his own series AS Robin that lasted years. Now he's kind of like a red-headed stepchild because of Damian Wayne and his only job is the Teen Titans. Even so, he's the smartest Robin, and the deadliest, because he wasn't just trained by Batman but Lady Shiva too. All that shit that Jason Todd went through in the new 52 doesn't really compare because there's magic and spirituality mixed in there, Tim Drake is grounded in physical reality like Batman and Nightwing, guns and knives are a cheat anyways.

Side: Red Hood
RobinofDC(6) Disputed
1 point

Since when are knives a cheat? I can think of a few occasions when Batarangs are used as knives in the comics.

To your 'smartest and deadliest' comment- I can agree with the smartest part, no matter how much i hate RR, I agree with that. But DEADLIEST?! HA! Here are the reasons that is untrue;

A. Jason defeats him WITH EASE everytime they meet, even when Tim cheats by bringing in weapons before Jason does.

B. Dick could most likely easily defeat him too, because even though Tim is the smartest, Dick isn't stupid, and is in fact pretty smart too.

C. When him and Damian fight, Damian, the 10 YEAR OLD, gives him a good fight.

I think Tim is the least interesting of all the Robins, but that's just me...... and most my friends. There are other reasons I dislike him, and if you would like to discuss it, feel free to dispute this argument.

Side: Nightwing