CreateDebate


Debate Info

13
6
Yep. Nope. Chuck Testa.
Debate Score:19
Arguments:10
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yep. (7)
 
 Nope. Chuck Testa. (3)

Debate Creator

Dremorius(861) pic



Only Someone with a Twisted Mind could make a Hell

Aka God.

Ergo it is a contradiction over his moral status.

Yep.

Side Score: 13
VS.

Nope. Chuck Testa.

Side Score: 6
2 points

For a creator to create something, they must understand what they are creating. If that means understanding absolute evil, and creating it, is that not a corruption of a pure being? A pure mind should not have corrupted thoughts, as corrupt thoughts lead to corrupt actions, and corrupt actions are obviously contradictory from a being who is supposed to be all that is good.

Side: Yep.

Hell is only for horror movies. It would be a much better world if people would not talk about Hell.

Side: Yep.
2 points

God didn't create hell for mankind. Hell is Satan's "home". When Satan rebuked God, that's where he was sent, and it was only supposed to be a place meant for him and his evil ways. However, with the whole sinning in the Garden of Eden thing and yadda yadda, that changed, and now everybody can go to hell, which is sad, but that's life.

Side: Nope. Chuck Testa.
Dremorius(861) Disputed
1 point

Doesn't matter who he created it for, what does matter is the fact that he was twisted enough to even come up with such a place (read my argument to the left). And Satan's punishment is kind of infinitely harsh don't you think? Same with Adam and Eve in the garden of Eden. By the way God wired their brains, he would of at least been smart enough to tell that they would act in the way they did.

Read this: http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2008/04/mind_decision

Side: Yep.
BookBird101(574) Disputed
2 points

No. Satan's punishment was not infinitely harsh, especially considering how he still has an effect on humanity today. Adam and Eve's punishment I can say that it was harsh, but God makes rules, and if in the past (Old Testament), if you didn't follow them, then you had to suffer the consequences. However, in the New Testament that's different, since there aren't so many rules, and you can repent for your sins, etc.

And who knows, maybe God has some higher purpose for letting this happen the way they've happened. I'm not God, so I wouldn't know, but I'd love to ask Him.

Side: Nope. Chuck Testa.