CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
5
correct wrong
Debate Score:9
Arguments:8
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 correct (3)
 
 wrong (5)

Debate Creator

icwhyte(64) pic



Only open minded people are willing to debate.

After reading, watching & listening to hundreds of debates over hundred of subject i have come to the conclusion that only the open minded are willing to really debate (discuss the topic and make a desicsion on the outcome) and not just repeat the same mantras over and over again.

correct

Side Score: 4
VS.

wrong

Side Score: 5
2 points

If you mean to imply that debate can be a learning process for the open minded, then yes, I think you're absolutely right.

Side: Correct
1 point

Since you defined "debate" to be "discuss the topic and make a decision on the outcome".... which is the definition of open minded... you're saying that only the open minded are open minded.

So, yeah. Sure.

Side: Correct

I think it's only the open minded that actually read and inwardly digest the subject matter of the debate as opposed to just the title.

Considering you actually went to the trouble of defining what you meant by 'really debate', "discuss the topic and make a desicsion on the outcome", I find it curious that so many are willing to defend the narrow minded on the grounds that they will not change their minds in a debate.

Side: Correct

But just to participate in a debate? Not always.

And I should know, too. However hard I try to stretch my myself away from my standard thoughts and misconceptions, I still try to hold onto them (if only because I hate being wrong.) And there are people still who only want to bring others to their side, without even considering perhaps changing their own perspective.

Side: wrong
1 point

I do believe it takes all types of people and opinions to debate. I have seen it here at this site...and while many people are closed minded, they do make for really great debates!

Side: wrong
1 point

Only open minded people are willing to debate

Nope! Not around here... there are plenty of closed minded people that are willing to debate, they just won't change their mind... That is, in fact, the norm (for most).

Side: wrong

I agree with you completely most people are close minded, i used to consider myself very open minded but the fact is nobody like having to re-evaluate the way the view certain things, but still i think if you are prepared to engage with another person in a debate and take their arguments seriously you are less close minded than most out there who only seek reaffirmation in the views they already hold instead of challenging them.

Side: wrong
1 point

I personally think it's what you're debating on. Open-mindedness have nothing to do with it.

Side: wrong