CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
7
Rorschach Batman
Debate Score:13
Arguments:10
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Rorschach (5)
 
 Batman (4)

Debate Creator

Quocalimar(6470) pic



Rorschach or Batman

I don't know...make of it what you will, who do you prefer and why?

Rorschach giving a speech The Dark Knight's monologue

Rorschach

Side Score: 6
VS.

Batman

Side Score: 7
1 point

Rorschach seems a bit more interesting than a playboy who dresses up as a bat at night, lol.

Side: Rorschach
2 points

Rorschach is a dangerous, murdering madman. Literally. And if you're not getting that vibe heavily enough from the horrible movie, try the comic.(It's better anyways.) Batman is also crazy, but uh, at least he has his limits.

Side: Batman
TheAshman(2299) Disputed
2 points

Batman is just as much of a murderous madman, hanging people from planes, crushing them with statues and in junkyards, impaling them on swords, starving them to death and burning them to death whilst getting laid in front of their burning bodies amongst other killings.

://www.cracked.com/article20111the-6-most-brutal-murders-committed-by-batman.html

He also dragged a criminal through a plate glass window and gave him the choice to either bleed to death or tell him what he wanted to know and thats just the comics. In the 1989 movie he killed the Joker even stating his intention and in Batman returns fries one of the Penguins henchmen with the Batmobiles engine and shoves a bomb down a strongmans trousers before kicking him down a drain to explode, this last killing even makes him grin the man's psychotic.

Side: Rorschach

That article is hysterical. And I thought he was some super do good, never killed anyone, type of guy.

Side: Rorschach
lupusFati(790) Disputed
1 point

If he's as dangerous as you say, might be worth looking into.

Side: Rorschach
Warlin(1213) Disputed
1 point

There's not much to look into as far as Rorschach is concerned besides the bloody mess he made in the antarctic after Manhattan explod'd him. To be sure, Rorschach does have some neat appeal, but Batman's is a little more long lasting, and there's tons more development for that playboy than Rorschach, since he was a character developed for a single story.

Conveniently, I've done research on both of these characters for class,(Don't. Don't ask.) and while Rorschach is a neat character, he doesn't really stand much on his own, because of the elements of the plot in that story he plays into. A lot of the themes are lost if you compare just him to another comic-book character. I'm not much for cheesy superhero comics, but there's some pretty swag batman story-arcs out there, and he's a surprisingly endurant and multifaceted character. Definitely more lasting appeal.

Side: Batman
2 points

i think batman is much better than rorschach .

Side: Batman

Always support Batman.

Side: Batman