CreateDebate


Debate Info

26
38
agree disagree
Debate Score:64
Arguments:48
Total Votes:78
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 agree (22)
 
 disagree (23)

Debate Creator

feelingtruth(2776) pic



Shamanism=Quantum physics

http://sanctuary.net/article-modern-shamanism.html

Shamans are essentialy quantum physicists, and there is alot of evidence to back this up, and i can say for certain, because the shaman believes we are all connected, just like quantum physics, using vibrations to heal ailments (cats purr to heal broken bones because of the frequency they purr at)

They work on the energy level, which is what everything is, pure conciousness

If you want to dispute this, please, please give me evidence to show me im wrong, but you wont be able to... quantum physics is proving what we have known and been able to do all along... so you might as well all just start practicing shamanism, the oldest belief system we have

agree

Side Score: 26
VS.

disagree

Side Score: 38

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yufAa4oFyug is all i have to say to your disagreements

Side: agree
CriticalCat(13) Disputed
2 points

Your getting allot of votes which arnt associated with any comments.

I accuse you of multiple voting fraud.

Because your dumb enough to do that to try and make your flawed arguments look valid by tipping the scales.

It doesnt win if it doesnt argue.

It doesnt win if it doesnt do logic.

Side: disagree
1 point

or maybe because people like what i say at times? you accuse me of multiple voting fraud? sounds like someones getting a little bit pissy

Side: agree
6 points

I am not much of an expert on shamanism, but I like to think I'm somewhat knowledgeable about quantum mechanics.

The key difference for me is that quantum mechanics only deals with, well, the quantum. It doesn't cover spirituality, or consciousness, or any human construct. Only the subatomic.

Perhaps shamanism also deals with this, but I know that shamanism also has the spiritual side, which leads me to conclude that there is a difference between the two.

Side: disagree
Liber(1730) Disputed
4 points

I am not much of an expert on quantum mechanics, but I like to think I'm somewhat knowledgeable about shamanism.

The key difference for me is that shamanism deals with the mind; with the connections between spirit and body, and how to influence the self. It doesn't deal with the subatomic, or really anything that is commonly accepted as science.

Perhaps quantum physics also deals with this, but I know that quantum physics is largely based in scientific/mathematic theory, which leads me to conclude that there is a difference between the two.

Side: agree

Erm... isn't that exactly what I said ? Or was that satire of my comment? What's your point?

Side: agree
1 point

shamanism deals with connecting to the universe, bud, not just our mind, or our spirit, these are important aspects we must purge before we can connect with the universe, but once you lose self of "me" and realize all is one thing, you will have full conciousness, this is why bob marley always said I and I

Side: disagree
0 points

Actually quantum mechanics has a lot to do with conciousness, conciousness is everything http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRkDicwjRQs

Side: agree
ricedaragh(2494) Clarified
3 points

youtube videos with disabled commentary always makes my inner skeptic raise an eyebrow.

Side: agree
ChuckHades(3197) Disputed
2 points

In and of itself, quantum mechanics does not deal with consciousness. It only does if you make the link yourself.

Side: disagree
5 points

So much wrong, I don't even know where to begin.

Firstly, it's be far more accurate to call them Quantum string manipulators than physicists, but that is a complete insult to actual learned men, and their hard won information.

Furthermore, "cats purr, heals broken bones", what the fuck? Honestly.

You assume that a cat purring outside a broken leg for instance can bring bone cell elemental building blocks, completely into resonance, all of them, at the same time?

Given that bone is made up of a myriad different elements all necessary to actually make it bone, the cat's purr can simultaneously effect all of these different elements at the same time, meanwhile not altering the skin, muscle, nerve fibers etc in between.

They work on the energy level, which is what everything is, pure conciousness

Absolute wild conjecture. Energy=/= conciousness, no matter what way you want to spin it.

quantum physics is proving what we have known and been able to do all along..

As I assume you're talking about string theory, you claim that people have already known that there are many more physical dimensions than the readily observable four, or that matter is made up, at the fundamental level of loops of infinitely narrow one dimensional packets of energy that vibrate one way to becom an electron another to be a down quark and another to be an up quark.

They kept that well hidden, didn't they.

Maybe they should just close down CERN and get a couple of baked crusties to man handle some hydrogen atoms and describe everything.

Side: disagree
3 points

I have never encountered someone as credulous as you. You believe what you make up and you believe almost everything you read, or hear or see somewhere.

Side: disagree
0 points

no its called experience buddy, transcedental meditation... LOL i believe what i make up are you an idiot? shamans believe the universe is made up of vibrations, just like string theory and quantum mechanics, thats why we have holy sounds LOL sorry that ive read all my resources i give, my god, you people fill me with hatred due to a sheer lack of comprehension, seriously, the education system sure is doing a good job of cutting off your awareness

Side: agree
nummi(1432) Disputed
2 points

You actually believe what you just said...

Not everything that has ever been made up is real! Try differentiate nonsense and truth! They are not one and the same!

Side: disagree

Quantum physics does not show that you can heal yourself through vibrations. Neither does it show that you can make it rain by dancing or work magic by chanting certain incantations. Also, I'd like to know where you got the thing about cats purring from, it smells like bullshit to me.

Side: disagree
feelingtruth(2776) Clarified
1 point

well i didnt read about it from wikipedia but: The vibrations and contractions of a purr work during both inhalation and exhalation show a consistent pattern and frequency around 25 Hz; these frequencies have been shown to improve bone density and promote healing in animal models and humans http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pura

Side: agree