CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
0
European Union United States of America
Debate Score:4
Arguments:4
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 European Union (4)

Debate Creator

Capitalist(48) pic



Should Britain join the EU or the USA?

Britain is perhaps the most sceptical member of the European Union but why? It wants to hold on to sovereignty which is noble and understanadble but if it came down to picking a side, which one should we choose and why?

European Union

Side Score: 4
VS.

United States of America

Side Score: 0
1 point

I can see how a country would Join the European Union, but how do you "join" the United States? What do you mean by that? Please expound.

Side: European Union
1 point

Of course when I say 'join' I do not mean become the 51st state but rather "throw our lot in with them".

I must say that in the past European powers have been at war with each other but that's because all of the superpowers were located in one small area (i.e. Europe) with China and India becoming increasingly powerful and other nations such as Russia, Brazil and South Korea gaining more power than the UK, it seems logical that the UK must seek to give up at least some sovereignty as opposed to holding on to this idea that we will become the world's greatest empire again.

Side: European Union
1 point

This argument clearly is showing how the U.K is becoming the '51st state.' This argument has been presented time and time again, the U.K must work to loosen ties between U.K and U.S. Britain's future lies in Europe...

Side: European Union
0 points

Screw the both of them, Britain did better than either of them ever could.

EU: thsi would fail as throughout history European countries have always been against each other, the idea of uniting just to beat other powerful countries will never work.

USA:How ironic, USA used to be part of the British Empire and now people are thinking we should join them?

Side: Neither
No arguments found. Add one!