Should it be a crime to slaughter and eat your pets?
Yes
Side Score: 14
|
No
Side Score: 16
|
|
|
|
2
points
1
point
But for people like me who come from local farming backgrounds, the livestock are nothing less then pets. We name them, pick favorites, even sleep with some of them as you would a dog or cat. Why isn't it wrong to kill and eat a cow or chicken if its wrong to eat any other house pet? They are no less of an animal,and certainly not any less intelligent, pigs are often much more intelligent then your normal cat and almost always smarter then any dog. Or are you in the position that all animals should be immune from being eaten? That would just be illogical to quite the extreme. Side: No
Yes, I believe it should be a crime. For this reason: you said slaughter. Slaughter implies inhumane actions against said pet. This being said, I believe it should also be a crime to slaughter anything. There is a big difference between humanely taking the life of something, and slaughtering it. Side: yes
1
point
1
point
0
points
4
points
Do you eat meat? If the answer is yes, then your comment is hypocritical. I don't mean to sound rude or bring your feelings down. :) I just gave your comment a two second thought and it hit me.....you said inhumane. It is not inhumane. Humans need meat to survive. In my own personal comment to this debate, i stated that we now have meat substitutes. But what about for the people who don't have substitutes? It is not inhumane to slaughter because slaughtering was one of the needed skill to survive. Human in the past needed meat to survive. Is it inhumane now that we be other options??? As a human, no. LOL, it is inhumane to sell pets and buy food with money. That to me is inhumane because that is not a skill needed to survive. I could be wrong because im nearly positive. Dunno. Downvote. Side: No
|
4
points
Honestly, there are two ways to go with this debate. I feel like that it is not wrong because our society is fine with cow meat, chicken meat, fish meat, etc and etc. So if our society is fine with it, then i don't see how it is illegal to slaughter your own animals for food. I feel like it is a crime because i don't think we need to slaughter animals anymore for meat. We have tofu, and a vegan diet that will give us nutrition that meats has done for us in the past. What do you mean crime? Legal Crime (society crime?)? Or (Religious crime? Moral crime?) Side: No
1
point
0
points
2
points
0
points
0
points
1
point
|