CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:5
Arguments:5
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Should our troops be pulled out of Afghanistan (5)

Debate Creator

manxbiker(13) pic



Should our troops be pulled out of Afghanistan

More and more of our troops are being killed out there they seem to have bad equipment and it seems a pointless war what do you think and why

Add New Argument
1 point

Pointless war, un-winnable. But we shouldn't begin pulling out until the country has at least stabilised, it would only make things worse upsetting the balance of power so suddenly, especially after upsetting it so much going in there in the first place.

Side: Not yet
1 point

i partly agree with you but how will we ever know if it is stable we will only have the word of the politicians of when it is stable

Side: Not yet
1 point

It's impossible to win that war, especially in the mountains. If we pulled out now though, it would seem like Vietnam part 2. Once they set up a semi-stable government like Iraq, I think they will pull out.

Side: Not yet
1 point

i think this si an unwinable war because why are we there in the first place "supposedly looking for osama bin ladin" but how do we know he is there?

Side: Not yet

It is now 2015 and the troops are still over there. They should come home right away.

Side: Not yet