CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
7
Why not? Of course not!
Debate Score:14
Arguments:12
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Why not? (6)
 
 Of course not! (6)

Debate Creator

DaWolfman(3324) pic



Should people serving prison sentences be permitted to vote in elections?

Why not?

Side Score: 7
VS.

Of course not!

Side Score: 7
2 points

I cannot see why they shouldn't, I mean with all that time on their hands the least they could do is read the newspaper get an opinion on who they want to see running the country. Just because they made stupid decisions doesn't make them stupid.

Side: Why not?
1 point

It should be like school where you have eligibility to be able to participate in certain events. If you are in jail for murder then there are certain things that you should not be able to vote for , but if it's a minor offense then yes they should be able to.

Side: Why not?
1 point

universal suffrage always!! I choose not to vote but i should always have that choice.

Side: Why not?

If a prisoner can study in prison and get a college degree, I see no reason to deny him from voting.

Side: Why not?
2 points

Why should they? They have lost all of their rights and for a good reason. Why should they have the right to vote if they do not even have the right to say what they want to? ( unless they enjoy solitary confinement )

Side: Of course not!
1 point

They have already lost that privilege, that should be the last thing that they should be worrying about. They should be worrying about what is wrong with them as a whole for committing a crime that sent them to jail in the first place.

Side: Of course not!
1 point

That is not altogether true. Please do some research so you can debate the subject properly.

Side: Of course not!

I'm going to direct this to convicted felons still serving their sentences and the aftermath of serving. No convicted felon is able to vote in any election unless they are from Maine. Massachusetts or Vermont. The dilemma comes later, after their sentences are served. Most of the states restore the felons rights after their sentences are served but not all of them do. There, then, is the rub! Please read the story on the following link as it has everything you should know about voting rights.

Supporting Evidence: Should Convicted Felons Have Voting Rights? SpeakOut.com (www.speakout.com)
Side: Of course not!
DaWolfman(3324) Disputed
1 point

But I would like to know your opinion on the matter and not be directed to see what other people have said on the matter.

Side: Why not?
1 point

I was just coming back in to do that...LOL. Me forget too much!

I think that not voting is something that is right and proper. There's an argument I am on the fence about pertaining to the idea that prisoners who are coming back into the mainstream should be able to have a say in the world they are coming back into. While I can understand that on one level I cannot fully agree. They didn't give a hoo-frigging-ha about anything when they committed their crime, small or large, so why should they be granted the biggest and most important privilege a citizen can have? What I think is that all states should recognize that these people have served their time and full privilege, in this case, should be restored to them when they leave. As long as they are incarcerated, no voting should take place by them.

Side: Of course not!
1 point

While serving a prison sentence, I think it makes sense that that is one of the rights taken from them. The idea is that they are being removed from our society, and anyone else not a part of our society does not have a right to vote.

I think though, that once our Justice System, as imperfect as it sometimes is, has deemed a person to again be part of the general population, than it does not make sense to still hold from them certain rights.

I think that if it is the opinion of the courts, that a specific person is now able to function in society, then they should be given all of the rights of citizenship. Otherwise, if they have not earned back all these rights, why are we letting them out to begin with? I think it's an indefensible position.

Side: Of course not!
1 point

It goes with the punishment of being in jail in the first place. If a man commits a crime and is sent to prison, he is stripped of all of his rights as an American citizen until he is released. This includes voting!

Side: Of course not!