CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
10
Yes No
Debate Score:19
Arguments:16
Total Votes:22
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (9)
 
 No (7)

Debate Creator

Srom(12206) pic



Should schools monitor what students do on the internet?

Yes

Side Score: 9
VS.

No

Side Score: 10
1 point

As a student, I really really want to say no. But the truth is that students should definitely be monitored. Because, as a student, I know what other students are capable of doing, and what they would like to do if only they had a few more freedoms. Serious damage to public school networks, library files, local school files and records. Because all of the computers are connected to the same network, it isn't safe for the school records or networks to just give a student free reign over the internet.

Side: Yes
1 point

Schools are institutes for education. The internet service is provided to support that intended purpose. Consequentially, it is reasonable for schools to monitor what students are using the internet for. There is not reason that students need to use the internet for anything other than educational purposes while they are at school, and in particular when they are in class. As far as whether schools should monitor students' use of the internet, I think that might depend upon the need to do so versus the resources it would take to do so. Restricting certain websites is a more efficient option, particularly if abuse of the internet is not a significant problem.

Side: Yes
1 point

My school has a very effective system in place. From a central location, teachers/administrators are capable of monitoring student internet use. This is only done when there is strong suspicion that a student is using it inappropriately.

My school is a private, college preparatory high school and therefore demands success. I think its reasonable for the school to want every student's best and support that through an accountability system. This is very much within their power as they are providing the computers. Anything else would be an invasion of personal privacy.

Of course, misuse of the internet is somewhat rare here, so it never really has been much of a problem anyway.

Side: Yes
1 point

Of course internet access should be monitored by schools. The majority of teens and children are immature, to put it blunt. I'm a student, and I realize some websites are necessary for educational purposes, but only those sites should be allowed access. After all, allowing them to roam to whatever site they want is being...counterproductive, and wasting the teacher's and student's time and resources.

Side: Yes
1 point

Yes, they should.

The purpose of schools is so that students can gain a good education through the environment and teaching standards around them. They can learn with their friends, through clubs, societies, school libraries and ... through the Internet.

If the standards are not suitable for learning on the Internet then the students' education standards may begin to decline and their quality of work may not be so good - ruining their future.

Schools should monitor what happens on the Internet.

Side: Yes

Children should stay on the project given to them and not go venturing to other websites.

Side: Yes
0 points

Yes I think they should monitor what students do because sometimes they can look up thing they shouldn't like porn.

Side: Yes
1 point

Not if a school has proper blocks in place, like mine did when I was in highschool. What purpose would monitoring solve anyways?

Side: No
0 points

Clearly the answer is yes. Just like I monitor my kids Internet access, primarily because I don't want to go to jail for them doing things like surfing sites they shouldn't be surfing! So too should schools monitor their Internet users.

Side: Yes
2 points

Monitor students? Meh. I disagree. There's already the capability to block certain websites, and that's sufficient enough to prevent anything the students shouldn't be looking at.

And yes, I know there are proxies to get past such security functions, but anyone who has that knowledge probably has the ability to get past computer monitoring.

Side: No

On school computers? Yes. Anything else? Of course not, its an invasion of privacy and considered most schools are government run public schools, this has alot of room for corruption.

Side: No
Jace(5222) Disputed
1 point

If the students are using the school network (which is the only way the school could monitor their use) then it is not an invasion of privacy because it is not a private or personal network. There is also an express purpose for the internet being provided (i.e. education). Abuse is a reasonable concern under any circumstance, but any authority granted to one entity over another entity can be abused. That alone is not enough reason to make it wrong, unless it has a unique likelihood to be abused which I don't know that it does. Moreover, there are recourses for abuse of power.

Side: Yes
2 points

Nah, it'll make you feel good when on results day, you see the twat that spent all his lessons on porn and facebook get an F, and look all shocked 'cos he thought he was too smurt for schooling ;)

Side: No
1 point

Actually not a bad point at all. As long as the student is not disrupting others I suppose they had it coming and you have to learn sometime.

Side: No

Schools are fully within their legal right to monitor the students on school owned computers. As for whether they should do it, I would say no.

If they already have the blocks in place that prevent them from going to "dangerous" places on the internet, then what purpose would monitoring have?

Side: No
1 point

JUST SHUT THE HELL UP SCHOOLS SHOULD NEVER LOOK UP ON THE INTERNET IM ON A SCHOOL ONE RIGHT NOW

Side: No