CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:24
Arguments:15
Total Votes:26
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Should teachers have so much control over students? (14)

Debate Creator

sellersjes12(22) pic



Should teachers have so much control over students?

now clearly some lines can be drawn like "kids i'm teaching please quiet down" but what about teachers controlling kids clothing, hair color, ect.??? curious as to what people think
Add New Argument
3 points

Life is full of rules and regulations with employers having dress codes and personal appearance preferences.

I feel my confidence in a policeman with long lime green hair, shocking pink tunic top with polka dot trousers and a bone through his nose, would be somewhat diminished.

Maybe my judgment could be described as prejudiced, but that's the way of the world and the sooner students learn the necessity to conform to the expected norms of the society in which they live the better.

Schools have an image which they want to project and dress code along with personal appearance will form part of how they wish to be perceived by the public at large as well as teaching their students some of life's disciplines.

very good point i had not thought of it in the view of life lessons.

2 points

Self expression is fine but where do you draw the line ?

Is there a point where it goes to far ?

If yes ,what we are talking about is limited self expression .

1 point

You mean "too far". Apparently your school DOES need some changes.....

Dermot(5736) Disputed
1 point

The spelling police are about 🙀 I think you may wish to read a couple of your own rants and ponder on your own schools inability to give you a basic education .... then again you owned several properties before you were 38 .... so you say 😳

It's fine, though, but children should not be punished if they don't strictly conform to it.

Otherwise it'd just be for the teacher's aesthetic appetite, rather than any special purpose.

2 points

The entire school should be subject to a standard code of conduct (which may or may not include a dress code). Teachers are empowered to administer that standard in their classroom, and if there is a disagreement over whether they are doing so fairly then that should go to the Principle or ultimately the Board to render a verdict upon.

Certainly some teachers go too far in wielding their powers, and others not far enough. But what is generally true in schools is a sizeable subgroup of students are willing to test the limits of rules, which is usually what triggers the tougher teachers into becoming so tough.

3 points

So the girls should wear burkas, and the boys should wear turbans? Sick.

I would like to start on the topic of hair dye. now in my school kids can be suspended for having their hair to bright of a color as it is considered "a distraction" but i feel this is a form of self expression especially in younger kids and teens who are discovering what they want in life. Thoughts?

1 point

The school has an obligation to teach, not to allow self expression. If self expression interferes with the teaching process then it needs to be stopped.

You need to work with the school to get the policy changed.

1 point

Teachers should have those kids chained to the floors with the whips out. ADD would then be history.

negligent(202) Disputed
1 point

Why isn't this account banned yet? Interesting....

sellersjes12(22) Clarified
1 point

sorry could you please explain why you made this statement? i'm confused as to what happened that is so bad...