CreateDebate


Debate Info

16
12
Oh God Yes! Nah... it's all good
Debate Score:28
Arguments:19
Total Votes:41
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Oh God Yes! (9)
 
 Nah... it's all good (8)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



Should the Bible be Rewritten to Make Sense for the Today?

Oh God Yes!

Side Score: 16
VS.

Nah... it's all good

Side Score: 12
1 point

It was rewritten to make sense for those who don't understand hebew, and then latin in the first place, so I guess it would be in keeping with the point of it actually being readable.

Side: Oh God Yes!

Good idea! The Bible should be re-written in 21st century language and Leviticus 20:13 should be removed.

Side: Oh God Yes!
0 points

I mean that's the idea of The Message. In my opinion it just ends up sounding really weird and very non-scripture-like, but that isn't to say it is better or worse.

Side: Oh God Yes!
1 point

The Message just makes it easier to read... I was thinking more like should some of the ideas be updated... throw in a little evolution or something.

Side: Oh God Yes!

Yes. Next question!

Side: Oh God Yes!
1 point

Don't use my Yes, next question!

Side: Oh God Yes!

How about Who cares? Next!

Side: Oh God Yes!
Depressed(355) Disputed
1 point

As a Libertarian you should appreciate violation of Copyright Laws.

Your fellow men led the fight against SOPA, after all.

Side: Nah... it's all good
0 points

Hell ( sorry) why not because all the atheists keep taking it out of CONTEXT ( very important ) and the good "Christians " have to help them. God told all the good Christians to reinterpret his book as they saw fit , he wasn't very clear on what he wanted to say , lucky the guys had his tail. So maybe this time make it easier for the atheists ( we love it) to understand ... Can't wait .

Side: Oh God Yes!

No, you can not change the word of God. Only God can change the word of God.

Side: Nah... it's all good

God would still be the author, speaking through his interpreters.

Side: Nah... it's all good
2 points

Ok then I think we should ask God first.

Side: Nah... it's all good
1 point

Sure, and while we're at it, let's re-write the Iliad and the Odyssey, and re-build Notre Dame and the Taj Mahal to give them a more modern look as well. Old stuff sucks.

Side: Nah... it's all good
Elvira(3446) Clarified
1 point

You would have a point if the bible hadn't already been translated about 3000 times from Hebrew, Latin... and in the last few hundred years to English, German, French, Hindi, Arabic, Binomial...

Side: Oh God Yes!
LeRoyJames(372) Clarified
1 point

I think this depends on what is being meant by "rewritten to make sense for today". If you're talking about a new translation to use a more modern language, but to still keep the original meaning, then I would agree with you. However, I think what's being asked for is to remove references to selling your daughters into slavery, and even a new explanation of Genesis and some other the other concepts in the Bible. Although I'm not opposed to such a project, and in fact it's arguable that modern science and philosophy books do just that, I don't think any such book would be entitled to claim the legacy of "The Bible".

Side: Oh God Yes!

It was already rewritten countless of times. Through mistranslation and political corruption

Either you find the original documents or ask the author for the real story. Otherwise, further modification will only add insult to injury

Side: Nah... it's all good
1 point

Imparting our particular biases onto either a divinely inspired book (theists) or a book that has compiled the cultural wisdom of one of the oldest surviving groups (atheists) is a bad idea, it destroys the value that is imparted via the cultural refinement and wisdom of a culture that survived for 5000 years.

Should we rewrite the Odyssey? The Illiad? The Inferno? Kant? Should we discard all such classical wisdom for our own peculiarities?

As G.K. Chesterton said, "fallacies do not cease being fallacies because they become fashions."

Side: Nah... it's all good

I think we should just get rid of it personally, it has revised itself a few times already, in efforts to adapt with the modern world.

Side: Nah... it's all good