CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
3
Yes No
Debate Score:12
Arguments:11
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (7)
 
 No (3)

Debate Creator

Cuaroc(8840) pic



Should the Movie Eragon be remade

Yes

Side Score: 9
VS.

No

Side Score: 3
2 points

I really think that Eragon should be remade they did a decent job the first time but their was a lot of room for improvement.

Side: Yes
1 point

Everyone acts as if they have just acquired their motivations and history on a 3x5 ... would be suspiciously appropriate myths and folktales every time Eragon .... your sure that it will be an ingenious piece of work (such as Tolkiens LOTR). ... I don't really think it's so much the "he stole from Tolkien/Lucas/Ghandi/God/my dog.

Supporting Evidence: lease trader (eleaseit.com)
Side: Yes
1 point

Yes it should. The other movie sucked! They need a new directer and better people to play the characters again

Side: Yes
1 point

Yes it should .

Side: Yes
1 point

Although I think that BenWalters has a good point, I was so disappointed by Eragon that I think a major re-haul is in order.

Side: Yes
2 points

they should make it a mini series, those are the only good films out latly, movies have been sucking. Band of brothers and spartacus and walking dead are great because of them being mini series or short season installments. allows for great charecter growth. also game of thrones is the perfect example of how successful the inheritance cycle could become

Side: Yes

As much as I loved the books (I have all of them), they're too long and complex, and don't work as a film. Too much speech, thought, and don't work in a visual form. So no, they shouldn't spend their time remaking it.

Side: No
1 point

It is a good book, but who would remake it? It has already failed once.

To someone who doesn't know about Eragon, it could just sound like a rubbish version of Lord of the Rings.

Side: No
Regarding(11) Clarified
1 point

maybe because that is where he drew much of his ideas from.

Side: Yes

No, ah he'll no, dear sweet baby Jesus no! god no! please no the first one sucked

Side: No
Cuaroc(8840) Disputed
1 point

that exactly why the movie should be remade because the first one was bad.

Side: Yes