CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
28
Fair Foul
Debate Score:30
Arguments:20
Total Votes:32
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Fair (1)
 
 Foul (18)

Debate Creator

KingOfPopForever(6910) pic



Sixth Grader Banned From School for Dyeing Her Hair Pink.

If you go to Shue-Medill Middle School in Newark, Delaware, you might want to think twice before getting creative with the hair dye. Sixth grader Brianna Moore was banned from school for three days for dyeing her hair pink until officials changed their mind on Tuesday, Reuters reports.

Administrators reversed their decision after getting a call from the Delaware branch of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) -- so Brianna went back to school on Tuesday. "We're on our way right now," Kevin Moore, father of 12-year-old Brianna, told Reuters as he drove his daughter to school.

Moore helped Brianna dye her hair a shade called "crimson storm" (her idea) as a reward for improving her grades. But she was quickly sent home from school and told not to return until her hair was a "natural color, brown, blond, black or natural red/auburn," in accordance with school policy.

After the ACLU called claiming the ban was "unconstitutional," Moore was invited back to school and promised she wouldn't be punished, Reuters reports. Score one for the ACLU (and Brianna) ... but should Brianna be punished for breaking school rules?

Fair

Side Score: 2
VS.

Foul

Side Score: 28
1 point

Good riddance, people like that don't belong in school, they belong in prison.

Side: Fair
Akulakhan(2985) Disputed
1 point

Whothefuck doesn't belong in school that isn't causing harm?

Side: Foul
Saurbaby(5581) Clarified
1 point

Would you mind explaining why someone who dyes their hair deserves to be in prison?

Side: Fair
4 points

Is it a public or a private school? If the latter, then they ought to have the right to suspend or expel those students who fail to conform to any of the school's outlandish requests. However, if the school is a public one, then they have not that right. In our current society, it is generally felt that everybody has the right to an education; nothing as ridiculous as dying one's hair ought to take away that "right".

Side: Foul

What else would it be other than a public school? The American Civil Liberties Union wouldn't get involved unless the school was public; otherwise, it wouldn't be a matter of constitutionality.

Side: Foul
4 points

When I dyed my hair purple I got sent to the administrators office. But when I got in there he looked at me and the write up and told me this was a waste of time. I honestly think the teacher just didn't like me. X)

It's stupid, I think new tattoos are more distracting to students. And there's not much they can do about those. lol

Side: Foul
2 points

It doesn't even look pink- it looks ranga (or red head.)

That is a dick move what the school did, and it is totally anti-educational.

Side: Foul
2 points

The school had no basis for suspending her. The color of her hair was not going to affect her or anyone else's work - this was just discriminatory.

Side: Foul
1 point

They have an irrational fear of pink-heads lol

Side: Foul

What?....haha wow!

Side: Foul
1 point

That was a violation of free expression rights.

Side: Foul

That is pretty foul. The only hair that I agree needs to be controlled is its length. But dye, seriously, I thought it would look silly and rebellious but is nice and respectable. And she got BANNED? Dress codes are okay, but banning her for dyeing her hair is just not Libertarian, I am a little more left than Libertarians but I still agree with some of their views.

Side: Foul

The only hair that I agree needs to be controlled is its length.

I agree with this statement if you have the ability to grow it back you should get it cut and donate with you cut to people who need hair and keep doing the cycle over and over because you will bless people with it. This is just my opinion I added.

Side: Foul
1 point

Wow! My school doesn't ban people who dye there hair. That is dumb and what was the school thinking!

Side: Foul
1 point

So, the childs hair needs to be a "natural colour?" What if the kid dyes their hair brown, or blonde? Some kids bleache their hair to a very fake looking orange. Is that a "natural shade?" because technically it is blonde or copper. both natural colours. Also, what if the child has brown hair, but gets tips??

Side: Foul
1 point

Maybe it's just the picture, but that looks almost like my niece's natural hair. I wonder if she'd be barred from school altogether.

At any rate, you'd think with how far behind U.S. schools are compared to most of the world, they'd have better things to do than worry about a kid's hair.

The endless string of moronic stories about horrible decisions made by schools convinces me we need to invest in making "teacher" a 60k+/ year job requiring at least a Masters in an actual subject -- and as a trade for the deserved pay and benefits, the right to immediately fire any teacher who cares that much about the color of a little girl's hair.

Side: Foul
1 point

OK uniform fair enough but apart from uniform hair is she has to style how she wants it's stupid she's only allowed a 'natural colour' (Not even my school is that strict :P)

Side: Foul
1 point

Public school students are allowed to freely express their ideas and creative instincts unless they purposely cause harm to another student. They probably just don't like pink. :(

Side: Foul
1 point

the pink is aresome and should be aloud be couse of there human rights so she/he has her /his so we can not comment on this

Side: Foul
1 point

I think its dumb. So what? The girl was being creative, showing who she was. Who is the school to stop her from showing people who she is? I want to dye my hair blue but i go to a private school so i cant. But honestly they tell you over and over to show yourself to th world, but if they dont let you dye your hair, if thats the way to show yourself, there holding you back!

Side: Foul