CreateDebate


Debate Info

14
19
Mankind has been a Plague! No! We have helped our planet!
Debate Score:33
Arguments:12
Total Votes:41
Ended:04/23/16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Mankind has been a Plague! (4)
 
 No! We have helped our planet! (7)

Debate Creator

SlapShot(2608) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

So, since today is Earth Day......A Question for you.






Since today is Earth Day it prompted me to think of a question for you guys.


Seems to me, and indeed most Biologists and Environmental Scientists, that the species of homo sapien has done nothing positive or productive for our planet. Some would say we have been as injurious to it as a plague. A virus, what with our pollution, razing of Rain Forest, killing of other animals, and absurd over population.

Do you agree?

Or can you think of some way.....ANY way..in which our species has helped the environment of this planet?

A helpful hint in answering....Please remember that advances or inventions for OUR own species is NOT the same as one that has actually been conducive to the health of the planet.

We are talking about the one and only home we have.......

EARTH!

Thanks.

Mankind has been a Plague!

Side Score: 14
VS.

No! We have helped our planet!

Side Score: 19
Winning Side!
1 point

I'm not going to say we haven't done something to help the Earth (although I can't really think of anything aside from cleaning up our own messes), but even if we have, the final net value is heavily on the destructive side.

Side: Mankind has been a Plague!
Hellno(17753) Banned
10 points

Huh! That picture looks like Detroit.... is that your back yard?

Side: No! We have helped our planet!
SlapShot(2608) Clarified
0 points

Nope....it was actually taken in 2014 at an estuary off of the Lake in Cleveland, Ohio.

Side: Mankind has been a Plague!
Hellno(17753) Disputed Banned
10 points

Cleveland, Detroit... same difference. They're both dumps.

Side: Mankind has been a Plague!
2 points

Personally, I value "green" initiatives whether they be reduce, reuse, reycle, or limiting pollution, or protecting nature, etc. But the fundamental flaw every time someone refers to homo sapiens as destroying the earth is that we're just another animal adapting our surroundings to what we think we need. If locusts strip a valley that's just nature, but if humans do it then we're destroying nature. If an invasive fish species like the snakehead kills off indigenous species that's unfortunate and we try to stop it but it's still just nature, but if human fisherman kill the indigenous species then we're destroying nature. Ants and termites dig and build homes but if we dig and build our homes we're destroying nature. And on and on. We're just another animal. Finding our aluminum can on the seashore technically isn't all that different than finding a shell a dead sea creature left behind, yet ours is trash and theirs is a beautiful shell.

I don't want humans to destroy the planet. But the act of living is not de facto the act of destroying the earth. It's just living. We can live wiser, just the same as a beaver should plan its dam wisely, but it's naive to think every beaver is going to make the best choice and likewise it's naive to think every act of mankind is a malicious selfish destruction of the world.

Side: No! We have helped our planet!
1 point

I have been on many lakes around the country spent 4 1/2 years on the ocean but there is one thing i can tell you i have never seen any of that trash in any body of water i was on.

Side: No! We have helped our planet!
1 point

We gave the Earth plastic. That's why we are here. We are here to give the Earth plastic and then go away.

Side: No! We have helped our planet!
1 point

I'm kind of on both sides because we were made to live on this planet, not to help it or destroy it. I believe as one of the many creatures we are on Earth, no animal is powerful enough to destroy a planet. You may see tons of trash everywhere. It might take a long time to decompose, but it still decomposes. So is it a bad thing?

Side: No! We have helped our planet!