CreateDebate


Debate Info

17
16
Yes-divides more No-unites more
Debate Score:33
Arguments:31
Total Votes:48
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes-divides more (15)
 
 No-unites more (14)

Debate Creator

xinyu(16) pic



'Social media divide more than unite.' To what extent is this true?

Yes-divides more

Side Score: 17
VS.

No-unites more

Side Score: 16
1 point

In a Newsweek article, Johannah Cornblatt explains “Social-networking sites like Facebook and MySpace may provide people with a false sense of connection that ultimately increases loneliness in people who feel alone.” John T. Cacioppo, a neuroscientist at the University of Chicago, claims that social networking can foster feelings of sensitivity to disconnection, which can lead to loneliness.

Many people have no idea who their 'Friends' are

Side: Yes-divides more
Lynnarella(2) Disputed
1 point

Like you ah? Bloop bloop bloop bloop bloop blooop bloooopp

Side: No-unites more
1 point

According to a research carried out by the CNN, there is a class divide that exists that is evident even in social media. Many of the more affluent users use Facebook while many of the less affluent ones use Myspace. This hence creates a division between the platforms used by the affluent and the less affluent to communicate.

Side: Yes-divides more
LowTzeHui(19) Clarified
1 point

I can understand if there is a digital divide. But if you have access to the internet in the first place, how is there perceived inequality between Facebook and MySpace users?

Side: Yes-divides more
1 point

Research suggests a multitude of explanations for the digital divide including, but not limited to: education, income, age, skills, awareness, race, ethnic origin, location, and gender (which is contested as being a confounding variable); political and cultural access; and psychological attitudes to Internet access and usage. Income levels and educational attainment are identified as having the largest explanatory power to explain ICT access and usage, with age being a third important variable, which means that prototypical "victims" to the digital divide can be foremost characterized as poorer, less educated, and older.

Side: Yes-divides more
1 point

Social media can make people more brutal about their viewpoints since there is no direct consequence of their actions. This may further harm human relationships.

Supporting Evidence: Social media makes more conflict (www.theonion.com)
Side: Yes-divides more
1 point
1 point

"As social media continues to alter how people connect personally and professionally, its impact on building culture in the workplace is debatable.

Examining perspectives on culture and business strategy, 41 percent of executives participating in the study believe social networking helps to build and maintain workplace culture, while only 21 percent of employees have the same view.

Moreover, business leaders and employees widely differ on whether social media has a positive effect on workplace culture (45 percent and 27 percent, respectively) or allows for increased management transparency (38 percent and 17 percent, respectively)."

Side: Yes-divides more
1 point

Social media may highlight class differences more. People with no social media due to parental restrictions or may be too poor to have access to internet may thereby feel alienated.

Supporting Evidence: Kids get ostracized when not on social media. (www.theonion.com)
Side: Yes-divides more

Some folks can be mean on Social Media sites and humiliate others.

Side: Yes-divides more
0 points

People sit at home poring over the details of their profile(most probably fake), instead of going out to talk to people

Side: Yes-divides more
0 points

Social media promotes narcissim. Updating statuses on facebook and spamming thorughts on twitter make us feel important. Narcissim is not celebrated in society. Unless you're Robert Downey Junior.

Side: Yes-divides more
lokyou(11) Disputed
0 points

Lynnarella can't spell. Therefore her argument is invalid.

Side: No-unites more
xinyu(16) Disputed
1 point

this has no relation whatsoever to the question. oh wait, it's related to the question indirectly. social media does divide more as apparent with your feud with her

Side: Yes-divides more
Lynnarella(2) Disputed
0 points

Whudddd... lokyou isn't a real word either. You no capitalize.

Side: Yes-divides more
Cynical(1948) Disputed
-1 points

Fallcious much?

Side: Yes-divides more
2 points

The recent Arab Spring is seen as a statement of freedom that Arab countries have been seeking for since years ago. Many know about the success of the Arab Spring but little know about the role of social media in contributing to this success. The Arab Spring heavily relied on social media such as Facebook. Evidence of the strength of the social media in uniting people is further proven in the agreement of Twitter to help the oppressive regimes of Syria and other Arab countries to censor tweets out of Syria. The founders of social media are aware of the power of social media and hence seek to ensure that social media is not continued to be used as a medium for 'suppressed citizens' to unite against their 'government'.

Side: No-unites more
1 point

Social media helps to foster closer ties between people since more social events can be developed from it. It can complement real life interaction.

Supporting Evidence: Power of social media (www.prweb.com)
Side: No-unites more
1 point

Social media unites people who have a common cause. The recently launched site named Neighborland started as a local neighbourhood project and has recently been adopted by the think tank of the co-founders of Twitter. This site enables people across the United States to share local ideas and opinions. The common platform unites people and hence urges them to push for a common cause.

Side: No-unites more
1 point

Social media can unite many people due to its ability to connect to many people(provided there is internet access). In the case of religion, a 32-year-old associate pastor at First United Methodist Church in Pontiac, Ill., electronic communications, if used properly, present a “new frontier” that can foster personal relationships, promote connectionalism and, ultimately, contribute to the denominational goal of “making disciples of Jesus Christ.”

This approach is also a way of connecting with the younger generation, as evident in the General Election in Singapore. Politicians are able to reach a more diverse audience and garner more support, as well as increase awareness about their campaign aims.

Side: No-unites more
2 points

Just to add on our Prime Minister has finally launched his very own Facebook account. Many ministries and government agencies also have Twitter and Facebook accounts to update their clients.

Supporting Evidence: Lee Hsien Loong's Facebook Page (www.facebook.com)
Side: No-unites more
1 point

Social media eliminates geographical barriers and boundaries, allowing people the chance to interact with others from over the hills and far away~

Side: No-unites more
1 point

Social media has the ability to unite people with a common cause and interest across countries

Side: No-unites more
xinyu(16) Clarified
1 point

are there any examples where social media has the ability to unite people with a common cause and interest across countries?

Side: Yes-divides more
1 point

social media is a medium for people to express themselves. it gives more opportunities and openings to a persons personal thoughts, feelings, insights into their life. eg CreateDebate

Side: No-unites more
0 points

EVERYONE CAN BE UNITED IN DISUNITY. Apparently the minimum length for an argument is 50 characters.

Side: No-unites more