CreateDebate


Debate Info

19
34
Agree Disagree
Debate Score:53
Arguments:25
Total Votes:63
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (11)
 
 Disagree (14)

Debate Creator

altarion(1955) pic



Some people should not be allowed to voice their opinions.

Agree

Side Score: 19
VS.

Disagree

Side Score: 34

Actually no. Apparently it has been proven that certain people do are not entitled to their opinions.

Supporting Evidence: Study: 38% of People not Actually Entitled to their Opinion (www.theonion.com)
Side: Do not take this argument seriously
pvtNobody(645) Disputed
4 points

Oh yes the onion, the source of all factual information...pleas tell me this is a joke.

Edit: Didn't see the tag. Sorry.

Side: Disagree
1 point

Hahaha. Nice. I love it when people post nonsensical articles like that. (;

Side: Do not take this argument seriously
3 points

"Some people should not be allowed to voice their opinions"

WHAT?! Everyone should have the right to express about he/she feels about certain issue, whether people agree with them or not.

Also Chris Crocker is an internet actor. He is on youtube for entertainment, not meant to be taken seriously.

Side: Disagree

If people were not entitled to their opinion then we wouldn't get stuff like this:

P.S. Did I mention I like trance? Hmmm, I guess this person is right, I do want more ;)

leave Britney alone trance mix
Side: Disagree
2 points

Excuse me, but if i have something to say i am GOING to be heard. If christina crocker has something to say then he can flippin say it, but other people do not need to ridicule someone's opinion just because they disagree. I KNOW i don't really agree with christina, but do you see me calling him a rainbow flying britney obsessed guy looking for attention ? NO. he was given a voice. i was given a voice. EVERYONE was given a voice. we have a right to use it no matter WHAT other people have to say about it.

Side: Disagree
xaeon(1095) Disputed
4 points

I disagree in part with what you say. Everyone should be allowed to voice their opinion, but in the same respect everyone else should be allowed to ridicule them for it if they so wish. It's two sides of the same coin which make up free speech. You have to be ready to hear both what you want to hear and what you don't want to hear.

If you say something stupid, prepare to be ridiculed for it.

Side: Disagree
2 points

yeah i see what you mean, but i think toni meant in a less unethical sense. Like i realize people will ridicule those who have the guts to say something, but the hostility is not neccesary, especially when they don't even know the person well enough, cuz they don't know what their life is like. they don't know why they believe in what they do...i think there should be more respectful ways of agreeing or disagreeing with other people. you know, be more civilized ?

Side: Disagree
2 points

But why ridicule xaeon? Must one be faced with being personally ridiculed, which is non-productive, instead of simply disagreeing with that person? Disagreeing in a good way opens the door to more dialog while ridicule slams the door SHUT and creates a hostile situation.

Side: At times I can agree with this
1 point

And the first ammendment gives us legal protection for ridiculing you too. (;

Side: Disagree
altarion(1955) Disputed
1 point

Some people would say that is just because you are a woman that you feel your voice is so important that when you speak everyone should listen. I for one think that only stuck-up obnoxious people feel that way and when people say that "if i have something to say i am GOING to be heard" then they really should not be listened to because their opinions are often nonsensical or very biased towards their own personal benefits. And like some people said, if you are going to say something no matter what, then we have the right to ignore you.

Side: agree
crossmyHEART(17) Disputed
2 points

excuse me ? don't you DARE be calling my cousin obnoxious ! she can be loud if she wants to and voice her opinion if she wants to and whether or not you listen, she WILL be heard by somebody. And you know what ? she is one of the most selfless people i know so don't you DARE say that her opinions would EVER be "nonsensical or very biased towards her own personal benefits" because she is one of the last people she would ever think about. Being a woman or having an "important voice" has nothing to do with whether or not she is worth listening to. People will ignore. no shit, no big deal. It's not her fault that she actually gives a shit but at least she does ! don't you fucking DARE act like she's some self centered egotistical loud mouth because she's NOT and never will be. I can't believe you even have the NERVE to say something like that about her !

Side: Disagree
1 point

It's not that they shouldn't be allowed to voice their opinions, but their opinions shouldn't become as huge of a deal as they have. I mean it is quite obvious, no matter what Chris or anyone says, that this video is either a huge joke, or a crazed fan who needs help. Exploiting this video in such ways is not the correct answer to respond to this cry for "help".

Side: Disagree
1 point

We should be encouraging critical thinking. Whether to voice them or not is personal choice.

Critical thinking has never been a strong point for the human race (see link) , but it's about time it became a strong point.

Supporting Evidence: Milligram Experiment (en.wikipedia.org)
Side: Disagree
2 points

yeah, i agree. The more you think of things critically, the more rational your statements will seem.

good job ! i didn't think you had it in you to make a smart remark, based on what other people have told me.

Side: Disagree
2 points

Hi crossmyHEART! I cannot believe you went OFF on altarion the way you did but I understand and temper my own reaction because you were trying to stick up for your cousin, Toni. It was, however, more than a bit over the top. But here's the thing...you think altarion insulted Toni by what he said and then you turned on a dime and insulted Jesus, someone you don't know at all, by saying this; "good job ! i didn't think you had it in you to make a smart remark, based on what other people have told me." The way you phrased that left a lot to be desired. I wasn't going to say anything since the four of us are allies but I felt I should on his behalf.

Side: At times I can agree with this

No doubt! Thanks so much for bringing the Milgram experiment to our attention. It was brilliant and very controversial for its time, I would imagine. It begs more reading on the experiments and their results.

Side: At times I can agree with this