CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
5
good humor racist
Debate Score:9
Arguments:4
Total Votes:13
Ended:09/30/08
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 good humor (2)
 
 racist (2)

Debate Creator

gunman(93) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Spanish slanty-eyes ad: good humor or racist?

Are we too PC, or is this going too far?

Spain's Olympic basketball team has an ad out with them making slanty-eyes with their fingers. The ad's running just during the Olympics, and only in Spain. The players say it was all affectionate humor, and that they were just doing what the photographer suggested. Are people getting upset over nothing and being too politically correct, or is this racist and offensive?

Photo and article (msn.foxsports.com)

good humor

Side Score: 4
VS.

racist

Side Score: 5
Winning Side!
2 points

There's no racial stereotype they're playing to, just physical appearance. If anything they're saying that they're getting ready to compete on the Chinese home soil. The players obviously didn't make the call, the ad people did, but even so, ads are supposed to be controversial. The ad seems like it's just some good natured humor. Any response by the Chinese besides coming out and eating some rice and beans before their next match would be reading way too much into the ad.

Side: good humor

Yeah, good humor, and the woman's basketball team is full of nappy-headed hos.

Side: good humor
kirstie1126(480) Disputed
1 point

It does not matter if the ad people made the call. You can still say that you are not willing to participate!

Side: racist
1 point

being racist isn't good humor. it's awesome humor. it isn't "good" cause people get offended by it. but it definitely is funny as fuck.

twas a stupid thing to do though... i mean, i laughed, but you lose respect that way.

Side: Racist Jokes are Funny