CreateDebate


Debate Info

20
11
Star Wars Star Trek
Debate Score:31
Arguments:15
Total Votes:37
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Star Wars (9)
 
 Star Trek (6)

Debate Creator

Megan3955-75(35) pic



Star Wars VS Star Trek

Personally, they are both stupid.  If I had to choose though, I would choose Star Wars.  Only because I grew up with it and Star Trek is REALLY stupid

 

 

Star Wars

Side Score: 20
VS.

Star Trek

Side Score: 11
5 points

Clearly Star Wars. Star Trek is stupid imo. But why is Star Wars stupid? Do you understand the concept of it. It is about the rise, fall, and redemption of Anakin Skywalker. Good triumps over evil. Watching all six movies in correct order tells an amazing story.

Also, Star Wars has a religious connection to it. It is a retreating from the book of Revelations to the book of Genesis. Luke redeemed his fallen father the way Christians believe Jesus will bring redemption to our souls.

Side: Star Wars
Elvira(3446) Disputed
3 points

It's sci-fi! It's not religious, and star trek is not stupid- it's just the camera work and music in the first series that is kinda crappy.

Side: Star Trek
3 points

The visuals (movies/tv) would go to Star Trek (IMO), however Star Wars has much more depth and story to it. The Old Republic era is an example. Plus, Revan is badass.

Side: Star Wars
2 points

STARRRRRRRRRRR WARRRRRRRRRRRSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Star Wars
2 points

Star Wars I love its a pretty good movie has a lot of action and adventure in it!

Side: Star Wars
1 point

I agree, Star Wars has way more action in it than Star Trek. Plus, the movies even start with an action scene. (A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back)

Side: Star Wars

"I am your father".

Side: Star Wars

Star Wars was way more interesting with that dynamic music score, the colorful characters, and the special effects.

Side: Star Wars
1 point

There is less background knowledge in star wars, it's all romanticised storyline- it's less real.

Side: Star Trek
1 point

I think they're both pretty dumb. The new Star Trek movie was okay though.

Side: Star Trek
1 point

I don't think either franchise is 'stupid'. If you don't like either one then why create a debate about both of them? That's just odd...

But, I digress. If forced to choose, I would choose Star Trek. I watched it more as a kid and therefore it holds a fonder place in my heart that Star Wars. I love Star Wars, but I prefer Star Trek just that little bit more.

Side: Star Trek
0 points

I personaly prefer Star Trek, Star Wars is close to it i'll give it that but i prefer ST over SW. I liked that ST had a bigger back story. SW did have a back story but it was just of the Jedi, ST on the other hand had more of a story, the Romulans, Vulcans and us.

Both are awesome and great ideas but i have to go with Star Trek on this one.

Side: Star Trek
lego3072(80) Disputed
1 point

STARRRRRRRRRRR WARRRRRRRRRRRSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Star Wars
Oiden(395) Disputed
1 point

Is a good movie, but none the less...

STARRRRRRRRRRRR TREKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Star Trek