CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
1
Star Destroyer ENTERPRISE
Debate Score:2
Arguments:2
Total Votes:2
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Star Destroyer (1)
 
 ENTERPRISE (1)

Debate Creator

ironman34698(235) pic



Star wars Star Destroyer vs Star treks USS ENTERPRISE. who wins?

Science fiction geeks of the world UNITE! We have a matchup that would make captain Kirk and Darth Vader shudder! The enterprise was 2379 foot long with barrier shields and warp (light speed) capabilities. It has Spatial torpedoes, photon torpedoes and phase cannons. The IMPERIAL 1 destroyer was around 5000 foot long with smaller shields but more armament: ion cannons, proton torpedoes, turbo lasers and anti fighter cannons + a compliment of 72 tie fighters.Star destroyers, however, did not have the maneuvering ability of the ENTERPRISE but the ENTERPRISE would have nothing to counter the tie fighters. BUT, would the small cannons on the fighters be able to penetrate its strong shield defenses? 

Star Destroyer

Side Score: 1
VS.

ENTERPRISE

Side Score: 1
1 point

Star destroyers can travel light speed while star trek ships can barely go warp 9 . Not to mention how many ships a star destroyer can deploy to help it attack the enterprise . Star destroyers are also larger and have more durability . They have very similar weaponry and the ability of the enterprise the beam their troops onto the star destroyer is a nice edge but they can only do 4 at a time . But those 4 might do a lot considering the storm troopers can aim worth a crap . I would give the edge to the star destroyer as those tie fighters will wear down the shields eventually .

Side: Star Destroyer
trekkified(15) Disputed
1 point

First off, warp 9 is actually over 1000x the speed of light. Secondly, Star Trek shields are completely immune to lasers, as they are designed to withstand phasers, a step up from lasers. The Star Destroyer is big, but has shields that barely work. The crew of the Enterprise is also cleverer, and could use their transporter to simply beam a photon torpedo onto the Star Destroyer's bridge. Sorry, but I think Star Trek beats Star Wars again today!

Side: ENTERPRISE
No arguments found. Add one!