CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
48
Fair game! Not right
Debate Score:57
Arguments:28
Total Votes:58
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Fair game! (6)
 
 Not right (22)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



TSA Made Elderly Lady Remove Adult Diaper: Ok or Not?

http://gawker.com/5815608/tsa-agents-now-harassing-elderly-women-with-late+stage-cancer

 

Fair game!

Side Score: 9
VS.

Not right

Side Score: 48
2 points

It's humiliating for the lady and I feel sorry for her, but what can security do?

People smuggle drugs or bombs in all sorts of unusual ways. If they didn't search her and she turned out to be a suicide bomber, everyone would criticise the government for incompetence.

Side: Fair Game!
2 points

I would agree with you if we had a problem with old lady suicide bombers, but so far... we don't. They need to racial profile like El Al.

Side: Fair Game!
Peekaboo(704) Disputed
1 point

Thing is, there have been other unlikely suicide bombers before (see my other post for examples). Security was being safe rather than sorry, which is exactly how they should have acted.

Side: Not right
2 points

How many suicide bombers has there been whom turned out to be an old lady? If any, please give the link? It is time to profile.

Government is incompetent because everything it does is done with a blunt object such as a bat or crowbar rather than be precise such as a knife.

Side: Not right
Peekaboo(704) Disputed
1 point

There is always a first. Especially with clandestine activities like this, criminals are constantly looking for new ways to evade the authorities.

Bombers who are under the age of 14:

http://www.newser.com/story/56746/iraq-busts-baby-suicide-bombers.html

Bomber who is a white person:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/iraq/article598536.ece

Bomber who is so old he has difficulty walking:

http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5hvEXur3DACm0-dG5ZGzNiSLdSHfw

Who knows that an elderly lady wearing diapers won't be next? Profiling helps you identify the most likely suspects, but it's only a matter of probability, not certainty.

Side: Fair Game!
5 points

Isn't time for the TSA to use a little common sense and do a little racial profiling?

Side: Fair Game!
4 points

That is beyond wrong. How would a soiled diaper be coming between their search. The only thing they are missing is actually sticking their hands on people. How inconsiderate of these idiots.

Side: Not right

Not only is it an embarrassment for the perverts at the TSA, but how really unnecessary they really are.

Side: Not right
3 points

Maybe they caught her smuggling in(or out) some sh*t.

Side: Not right
3 points

Tsk Tsk, Merlin! Shame on you :) !

Side: Not right
2 points

~Hangs head in shame~

Side: Not right
2 points

Oh, no you didn't.... LOL

Side: Not right
3 points

I couldn't help it...it was too easy.

Side: Not right
2 points

No, that is NOT ok! How humiliating for that poor old woman! How can they justify doing that to her? Like she is really going to smuggle something in her Depends!!

Side: Not right
2 points

and even if she wanted to smuggle something, let her have a little excitement before she dies!

Side: Not right
2 points

LMFAO!! I agree!! Hahahaaaaa !

Side: Not right
2 points

This is degrading, and not right at all. They could have made a pass for an elderly woman in a wheelchair no less. The article says she didn't even have another depend with her. They could have at least gave her one, as courtesy.

With whats happened in he pass few months, its understandable that their a little paranoid, but taking it to this extent is not right at all.

Side: Not right
1 point

Iell. Dirty! That do not. Older people really do not need diaper, that's what more babies!

Side: Not right
2 points

If they can't control their crap, they do!

Side: Not right
1 point

Believe me, they do. I've done clinicals in nursing homes and many wear them. Only they refer to them as adult briefs so it doesn't belittle the resident.

Side: Not right