CreateDebate


Debate Info

43
45
Superior Inferior
Debate Score:88
Arguments:54
Total Votes:124
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Superior (29)
 
 Inferior (25)

Debate Creator

Sulith(508) pic



The Aryan Race

The German race.

Superior

Side Score: 43
VS.

Inferior

Side Score: 45
2 points

I do not wish to create controversy amongst my allies or those with whom I consider to have fairly close relations, but I must say that for my entire life I have considered the Germans to be the stoutest, strongest, smartest people in the world. They fought two world wars, conquered most of the Western World several times; they conquered Rome; they were influencial in modern fields of philosophy and psychology; they are geniuses. Hitler could have won if he had not made one mistake: killing Jews, homosexuals, etc. Had he deported them and left it at that, he may have managed to hold the Third Reich together much longer. What have the French done for us? Given us disgusting modern art. What have the Italians done? Architecture. The English? The English language. But before all of them, there were the Germans. Deutschland, Deutschland - Uber Alles!

Wir sind Ubermensch!

Side: Superior
1 point

Well I agree with some stuff you say BUT the reason the Reich fell apart after invading Russia. Hitler and the famous Frenchman Napoleon made the same mistake of invading Russia during winter!

This is the reason of Germany losing the war.

Hitler did in fact try deportation first he deported aprox. 1 Million jews to Madagascar I have no clue why there but it was to much and then the camps started.

Side: Superior
3 points

Yes, I knew of Russia. My great uncle fought there. My great grandfather was in Africa, other relations were all over the world fighting for Germany. One was even SS, he was murdered after WWII. I agree that Russia was partly responsible, but I believe it was a multitude of factors including his extermination camps. What are your personal beliefs, Sulith? Are you German by birth or choice? Are you a Neo-Nazi? Do you agree with extermination of 'inferior' races?

Most of these arguments are guided by a profound hatred of the Germans, probably left-over hatred from WWII, that is why I have always attempted to avoid that topic and study Germans in the preceeding milleniums.

Side: Superior
2 points

This is the reason for Germany losing the war.

Hitlers soldiers were addicted to the drug Pervitin .

http://www.spiegel.de/international/0,1518,354606,00.html

http://boards.history.com/topic/World-War-Ii/Hitler-And-Drugs/700000534?messageID=800008739

Side: Superior
sulithhater(4) Disputed Banned
1 point

HITLER WAS AN EVIL PERSON AND SO ARE YOU! !

Side: Inferior
sulithhater(4) Disputed Banned
0 points

im sure thats just what your history teacher tells you, get a life. the aRyan race sucks!

Side: Inferior
1 point

I strongly believe that the term "Aryan race/Ubermensch/Master race" has been the recipient of negative abuse, subsequent of Adolf Hitler's use of the concept and term. His concept of "Aryan" was distorted, and was used for selfish motives, ie: his leadership of the Third Reich. "Aryan" is a remarkable race, with many accomplishments to its name. They are dynamic warriors, and ussually intelligent. But because Ubermensch is associated with Hitler, it has become offensive, and a subject which many IGNORANT people speak their minds upon, without knowing exactly what they argue about. The Aryan race has its faults, as do other races. Each has contributed to society - therefore there is no SUPERIOR race, there are just many differently talented races. The simple fact that the Aryan race has always been seen as an accomplished race is the result of its popularity among dictators and racist authors. Aryans should not be criticised or looked down upon because they are the ancestors of those who have wronged the definition of Ubermensch. It is the right of an Aryan to wish not to interbreed, but the Aryan may interbreed if he/she pleases! This idea applies equally to other races. It is disappointing that this generation does not attempt to fully understand the subject, and that many do not take a FAIR point of view. Please. Understand your opinion, how it affects others, and whether it is entirely logical. What would you say if I said the African race is superior? All "inferior", all "superior" arguments would fall apart.

Side: Same
trumpeter93(999) Disputed
1 point

I don't believe that they are superior or inferior.

I hate to mention it but they lost both of those world wars. They only conquered western Europe because of Chamberlains appeasements.

The French have given us... nothing except wars

The Italians were Hitler's ally and they gave us pasta and good food.

The English are here to back us up as they are an important ally.

Side: Inferior
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
0 points

Well, in fareness I agree that Germany seems to be pretty good at taking stuff over historically, espcially considering they are a landlocked nation.

But your, and the commenter with the Swastica avatar's disection of the reason they lost seems to be off.

1. There was proof Hitler was mentally insane, and it was beginning to take him toward the end of the war. As he had a standing order that no action was to be taken without his order, they lost some key battles in Russia while he was sleeping for sometimes up to 24hrs straight.

So under those circumstances it would have been a matter of time before the whole thing fell apart.

2. Yeah, invading Russia has proven to be a bad idea time and time again,

but pretend Germany had somehow taken Russia, the US still had a shit load of big bombs. Germany was not making it across the ocean in any alternate Universe.

Side: Same
Sulith(508) Disputed
1 point

It already was impossible to win any battles IN Russia because of the winter weather.

Russia Suffered the most KIA's out of WWII

Side: Superior
2 points

Ama_Deviant: I have spent the better part of the last decade reading about and observing these cultures; I did not wish to exclude any of them. Historically speaking, you are off (don't forget that in the next line, Sulith wrote "The German Race.") The Germans, when they destroyed the Roman Empire, migrated all over Eurasia and North Africa. Just about every European is of some Germanic ancestry. I agree that nearly every peoples have made great advances in their chosen fields; it is simply that my preferred fields (classical artwork, psychology, modern philosophy, mythology) are all very much German fields. Johann Wolfgang van Goethe was a very talented writer, said by some to have been the smartest man to have ever lived with an IQ estimated at 200 (can't recall where I heard that, so don't quote me). Hans Holbein, and a few Norse and Russians artists did amazing works, better than modern version of a masterpiece (i.e. three squares of varying shapes and sizes). I enjoy the cultures of every peoples, and once seriously considered becoming an anthropologist. If I could spend several years of my life living amongst each culture, I would do it; but reality says that I can't.

Had the debate said 'The Arab Race,' I would have put superior and gave my reasons, same with just about any other race.

Side: Superior
1 point

Hmmm...

From what I've read there's either no such thing as the Aryan race or if there is it's not the Germans.

You need to define the Aryan race first and then explain what it is that's so great about them.

Side: Superior
Sulith(508) Disputed
0 points

Read TERMINATORS response and then talk to me.

I have no time to respond to people who are ignorant.

Side: Inferior
Kinda(1649) Disputed
0 points

Yep I have. He's talking about how Germans are a superior race - which is easily disputable.

Since when were Aryans German?

I know I can easily defeat any arguments or 'evidence' that Aryans (if an actual race) are German.

Since they are not Germans then who are they? And what is it that makes them superior.

They are not German. That is my stance.

Side: Superior
0 points

Dude, you're the racist

rasicm=ignorance you tard.

God....how does your skin tone make you more superior? It's like saying that cause the hair on my arm is longer then most guys, im far more superior. In fact everyone with short arm hair should be sent to death camps and murdered by the thousands

isnt that what you're saying?

Side: Inferior
1 point

Personally, I find people of the Aryan race superior. Wow, did I just say that? Yes I did. Why? Well simple...

I am of the Aryan race and I have found that I am most attracted to blondes and I love blue eyes and green eyes. I'm not like the Nazis; I don't want to exterminate all other races. However, my personal preference in women is similar to how I look. And I think this goes for a lot of people. How often you you see interracial couples as compared to one-race couples? I think it's human nature to want to stay within your clan or tribe, like in prehistoric times.

Side: Superior
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

While the last sentence is 100% correct whether you knew it or not, clan mentality is human nature according to Anthropolgy Annual Addition 2003 here on my desk.

I think that "most" people are actually attracted to those who do not look similar to them. Everyone is different of course but if you are talking percentage wise...

Either way though, I think that it is a bit silly to believe that one race is superior to another, since the reality is humans are all one race,

The last race to exist beside us were Neandrathals, and they're dead.

Side: Same
1 point

I totally agree with you there. People who actually believe that other races are inferior are just terrible people. I mean, how could you be so backward in your ways that you actually believe every single person from one race is just a bunch of useless tools?

Side: Inferior
1 point

The origin of Aryan did not begin with Hitler.

The German master race.

They certainly claimed superiority.

http://www.schoolhistory.co.uk/gcselinks/sourcework/masterrace.pdf

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Ar⋅y⋅an ˈɛəriən, ˈɛəryən, ˈær-

[air-ee-uhn, air-yuhn, ar-]

–noun

1. Ethnology. a member or descendant of the prehistoric people who spoke Indo-European.

2. (in Nazi doctrine) a non-Jewish Caucasian, esp. of Nordic stock.

3. (formerly) Indo-European.

4. (formerly) Indo-Iranian.

–adjective 5. of or pertaining to an Aryan or the Aryans.

6. (formerly) Indo-European.

7. (formerly) Indo-Iranian.

Also, Arian.

Origin:

1785–95; < Skt ārya of high rank (adj.), aristocrat (n.) + -an

ref.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/Aryans

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Aryan Invasion — History or Politics?

http://www.archaeologyonline.net/artifacts/aryan-invasion-history.html

Origin of the Aryans

http://www.sciforums.com/showthread.php?t=66385

Side: Same
1 point

Ok, things that I notice on this arguement are that people are targeting that I'm attacking other races.

I'm not. I'm just saying that I think Germans are an/the Aryan Race.

And what makes any of you guys think that this has to do with me attacking any other races?

I'm not I don't even mention any other races in this. Read the description it's three damn words.

I didn't put "Germans are superior and all other races suck ass".

Side: Superior
1 point

The Aryan Race: What do you make of this? http://thearyanrace.info/

It is not about what you are (creed or colour) but it is about what you reproduce (your children).

Scandinavians have the highest quality of life of any peoples on his earth (FACT).

Side: Superior
-1 points

It is superior Hitler perfected the German race and he tried to preserve -building a entire city underneath Berlin- and did well.

Side: Superior
HGrey87(750) Banned
3 points

This is the most offensive load of horseshit I've ever seen on this site. And I'm going to be pissed if it gets removed. Cheers to free speech.

Side: Inferior
3 points

As much as I hate to break up make believe time:

link

There is only one race of humans, we just have different color fur like tomcats or something. A tomcat is still a tomcat.

The fact is put 99% in the exact same position from birth, and they will all grow up to act, learn, know, etc,

just about the same as anyone else would

The whole "race" thing is just societal or silly pretend time "I want to fit in with someone" bs.

Side: Same
1 point

I judge people by the content of their character, not by the color of their skin.

Side: Inferior
2 points

It's not really that it's inferior, but it's not all cracked up as one would try to convince you.

In fact, one of Hitler's top Eugenics Scientists (a harsh man indeed) said that the extermination of Jews was to protect the Aryan Race. He found that the Jews were an exceptional enemy and are a threat. Now... something that is superior should not feel threatened, should they?

Side: Inferior
Sulith(508) Disputed
1 point

One of the reasons the Germans were against the Jews is for the Hate Crimes that were on German foreigners in Poland and other eastern countries Germans populated between the time of WWI and WWII. Many Germans were slaughtered in towns throughout Poland by Russian Generals/Officers/ETC. That were JEWISH! Since I am not on my home computer I cannot link proof but I will ASAP. Jews from Israel would send there smartest peoples to Russian schools and which they joined there military and eventually got such orders from Stalin and were carried through "Gladly"

Side: Superior
3002135(13) Disputed
1 point

You idiot, its not how you feel if youre superior

It's that you actually think YOU ARE superior cause of your skin tone or the book you read at religous ceremonies

How are jews worse then you eh? Half the freaking bible is from the TORAH....

Side: Superior
ThePyg(6743) Disputed
1 point

I guess you can't read, because you seem to not know anything I was saying in my OP.

Anyway... I'm an Agnostic/Atheist and I don't think that the Jews are worse than me.

Side: Inferior
Sulith(508) Disputed
-1 points

Your an idiot i never said anything about jews being inferior

Side: Inferior

No... the cat-like alien space pirates dominate the Aryans... ALL HAIL BRAK!!!

Side: Inferior
1 point

Hmmm convincing haha Brak is intelligent haha he is alien of course he would be smarter etc

Side: Inferior
2 points

I don't believe they are either superior or inferior, but since the superior side has more points, I'm posting for the underdog. To clarify, the aryan race doesn't describe germans. Aryan is defined as fair-featured (blond hair, blue eyed) which I assure you many germans are not. Many non-germanic peoples are aryan (Czechs, slovaks, poles, russians), and conversly non-german, germanic people (the dutch etc..). My mom is aryan, and she's a czech. (I guess my dad's genes were too powerful [yes I said that]). So in summation, you were referring to germans obviously, but said aryan (the aryan that hitler spoke of, but was himself not even a member).

It is ludicrous to say that any people are superior or inferior. All races have their gifts and talents. You have white people, black people, brown people, indigenous people and asian people. All races are of benefit to themselves and others. Some are mechanically inclined, some are creatively inclined, some are inclined towards nature, some are inclined towards spirituality and the same is true for psychology. These are simply guidlines as any person can be born to any race, but race mentality and genetics plays a substantial role in development. Terminator, white people have Da Vinci, the 69 psychology, many technical sciences etc.., asians have confucious, the hijuuhattec, psychology, many technical and natural sciences etc.., brown people (eastern people between europe and asia) have Akhenaten, the kama sutra, spiritual philosophy and psychology, and many spiritual sciences, indigenous peoples have Tatanka Yotanka, (...not sure about their sexcapades but they probably had some pretty raunchy sex anyway), unparalleled natural sciences, and very deep psychological study, and black people have M.L.K, "once you go black, you never go back", and creative and magical sciences (music and voodoo for example).

While Bob Marley was no Jung, Jung was no Bob Marley either. We are one brotherhood, my friend, different pajamas, slightly different genetics, but we are one.

P.S. If you really must apply differences to the races, consider that white people are the most expansionist, cruel, war-mongering, self-righteous, and elitist of the races.

Side: Inferior
Fair Realist(2) Disputed
1 point

(The "Superior" tag does not convey my view correctly. Please disregard it) Your argument is undeniably fair and well reasoned, and I agree that no race is inferior or superior, Ama_Deviant. But your post script is not. It contradicts and unbalances your entire argument. Given the chance, any race could be expansionist, cruel, war-mongering, self-righteous and elitist. There is simply the fact that "the white people" (as if you believe this race to be alien) advanced more rapidly as a result of difficult conditions. I believe that "the white people" helped the world along to its current state of modernisation, just as other races have.

Side: Same
1 point

its inferior because by thinking that they are superior they acutaly make them selves loom inferior

Side: Inferior
1 point

Hitler failed! Everyone will be equal when the Lord comes back. Jesus is settling the debate!

Side: Inferior
0 points

They let hate lead them instead of common sense. Thoughts about how to truly beat all, flew out the window when they decided to senselessly kill Jews and others. So in the end they were stupid, their motives to destroy stronger than their desire to conquer.

Side: Inferior
0 points

dude im white as sour cream but im gonig to be honest, Ever see an athletic team that's not dominated by black people? They truly athleticly pass white people...so Ayrans lose. sorry =(

Side: Inferior
Sulith(508) Disputed
1 point

Watch the olmypics bro also the blacks in soccer this year lost to Germany =\

Side: Superior
Sulith(508) Disputed
0 points

And no again according to most professional sports more blacks try out for NBA and NFL than whites so majority is going to get on the team

Side: Superior
Euroscope1(90) Disputed
1 point

I am white and this is ridiculous, black people are faster and quicker than white people. Don't live in denial about it. Having said that the UFC proved that black people are not tougher fighters than whites (i'd say equal). In boxing they own us but the UFC proves that's not the case in a street fight

Side: Inferior